If I was in your situation it would come down to how much I would miss having a keyboard/mouse and if you frequently use windows side by side
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
iPad iPad vs Macbook Air Debate
- Thread starter iPadDad
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
If I was in your situation it would come down to how much I would miss having a keyboard/mouse and if you frequently use windows side by side
Honestly, if you really wanted to, you could run Android on the iPad.
So, yes you CAN get code editors on it but if you're in school as a CS major, you're not going to be using an iPad to code. If you're in a business, you're not using an iPad to code. Apple ain't using iPads to make their software products.
Screen estate might be ok at looking at code, but if you done coding and needed to split each workspace by half or even four, its just impossible. Might be cool for getting people intrested in coding in html, but java, css, and most other stuff, you're coding on a computer.
Maybe on iPad Pro though...that would be interestng.
But I haven't found Google Chrome to fix the issue either. For example, try going to Apple's website. Even if you force desktop mode, still doesn't work.
You are much better men and women than I am, but you're also the first person I've seen post that they think that creating and editing sophisticated or even middle-of-the-road Word or Excel files is anywhere near as easy on a tablet as on even a small notebook. Personally, I don't think it's an either/or debate. Apple is going to be very disappointed by your post, since iPad sales are shrinking and notebook sales are doing very nicely. You're going to put them out of business.
I am subscribing to this thread as I am waiting to build up credit at telmex so I can either get an ipad air 2 or macbook air. Originally I was going with the ia2, but looking at them a 128 gb ia2 it's really close in price to the bottom mba so the decision is hard. That's prices here in mexico where the ia2 is about 827.00 us and the mba is about 1000.us.
They are whispering..."both...both...both..." Or maybe it's "los dos...los dos...los dos..." that you're hearing? It's been way too many years since I studied Spanish. Or you could wait for the rumored iPad Pro and have a BIGGER screen than the rMB!
It's been way too many years since I studied Spanish. Or you could wait for the rumored iPad Pro and have a BIGGER screen than the rMB!
Lol, I wish I could but it's far too much money. I would have to wait another year to build up enough credit for "los dos".They are whispering..."both...both...both..." Or maybe it's "los dos...los dos...los dos..." that you're hearing?
The rumored ipad pro would be a good idea, depending on the price. I know nobody else that owns apple products, apple has priced most of us mexican's out of the equation.
Still, I prefer Coding on my Macbook rather than my iPad. If I have to carry around a BT Keyboard around its pretty much the same thing as carrying my mac. But I like it for casual use, like reading or internet browsing etc.
You are much better men and women than I am, but you're also the first person I've seen post that they think that creating and editing sophisticated or even middle-of-the-road Word or Excel files is anywhere near as easy on a tablet as on even a small notebook. Personally, I don't think it's an either/or debate. Apple is going to be very disappointed by your post, since iPad sales are shrinking and notebook sales are doing very nicely. You're going to put them out of business.
Hahaha, good, clean debating, Macrumors needs more people like you on this forum.
Et tu.
I've actually been thinking about why I feel that a small notebook works better for me than an iPad.
The mouse is the biggest thing.
Not being able to put two documents side by side is something I often have to do that I can't do with iOS.
The software interface contributes, Word and Excel still work better for me on a computer (OS X or Win) than a tablet.
I'd say that display size contributes but I can be much more productive on an 11" (well, 11.6") MBA than my 9.7" iPad Air, which isn't a huge difference.
Notice that I didn't say that OS X works better than iOS, because having access to the file structure is nice but in general doesn't really affect my ability to open, edit, save and send/share a document or spreadsheet.
It's sort of an interesting question (to me) because the differences in my real world experiences (Sandy was a real trial) are greater than I would expect.
And just so you know, I am absolutely certain that if you took all of my digital tools and told me I could only have ONE, I'd ditch the desktops, notebooks, phones, etc. and the sole survivor would be my iPad Air. YMMV, most people would probably keep either the phone or the notebook.
Been forced due to the 2gb ram to retire my MBA 2010 as my work computer. Now toting my MBPR daily between work and home. The main reason is limitations of iOS on the iPad.
I would love to use the iPad for transporting between work and home if it had user account ts like my other Mac notebooks for starters. We use iMessage at work instead of email for issues that need immediate action. And the Mac notebooks are great for that, as well as th iPad.
I would live the iPad Pro to be OSX based. The rMB is close, but need the iPad feeling here with my customers.
I would love to use the iPad for transporting between work and home if it had user account ts like my other Mac notebooks for starters. We use iMessage at work instead of email for issues that need immediate action. And the Mac notebooks are great for that, as well as th iPad.
I would live the iPad Pro to be OSX based. The rMB is close, but need the iPad feeling here with my customers.
I would like to know how close the A9X processor will be to current Intel mobile processors that are in MB's now? Also, the iPad will need at some point will need a first party input device to make more professional work easier. This collaboration with IBM should help leverage more proprietary apps that business/industries can use to make programs more specific to what they need in the future. We are getting to that point to where tablets will overtake notebooks but don't think we are there yet.
I have really come around to the idea of the tablet though and think the iPad is the best piece of tech apple makes. I thought I would never say that I much rather have an iPad that an iPhone.
I have really come around to the idea of the tablet though and think the iPad is the best piece of tech apple makes. I thought I would never say that I much rather have an iPad that an iPhone.
Correct. For many users, the MBA 11 is a perfect choice for portability and computing power. It would beat out any tablet in performance tests because it's still a laptop class processor and computer. Oddly, I don't think they sell that many of them compared to the 13" MBA and iPads. Interesting.
I'm also debating myself between a iPad Air 2 and a Macbook Air 11...
I've gonne back and forth with a decision, as most Apple users do, but after I decide on one I remember the cons of it and then go back to the other one and vice versa... Been doing this game for 2 weeks now...
The iPad/Macbook is not for me but for my fiancee, she is finishing her degree and will have to write her thesis for master (Pharmacy) this year so she basically needs something to write down stuff, not so much excel and things like that. Also for research etc...
I think an iPad is a solid choice if you have another computer in your household available, in my case she has my iMac if she needs to do something that she cannot do on the iPad.
Of course it also hurts the iPad chances vs Macbook's when all the bluetooth keyboards are crap except one that costs 180$ (I'm looking at you BrydgeAir Gold keyboard). On a side note anyone has it ?
If the Macbook Retina was 200 (MacbookR costs in Europe 1499 which is US $1650) less that would be my pick but I cannot justify buying another laptop with non-Retina resolutions...
I've gonne back and forth with a decision, as most Apple users do, but after I decide on one I remember the cons of it and then go back to the other one and vice versa... Been doing this game for 2 weeks now...
The iPad/Macbook is not for me but for my fiancee, she is finishing her degree and will have to write her thesis for master (Pharmacy) this year so she basically needs something to write down stuff, not so much excel and things like that. Also for research etc...
I think an iPad is a solid choice if you have another computer in your household available, in my case she has my iMac if she needs to do something that she cannot do on the iPad.
Of course it also hurts the iPad chances vs Macbook's when all the bluetooth keyboards are crap except one that costs 180$ (I'm looking at you BrydgeAir Gold keyboard). On a side note anyone has it ?
If the Macbook Retina was 200 (MacbookR costs in Europe 1499 which is US $1650) less that would be my pick but I cannot justify buying another laptop with non-Retina resolutions...
I'm sure there are some people who find it suits their needs, but for productivity, I would stick with the good ol' Macbook Air.
If the Macbook Retina was 200 (MacbookR costs in Europe 1499 which is US $1650) less that would be my pick but I cannot justify buying another laptop with non-Retina resolutions...
I personally feel that people put too much stock into "retina", but it's personal and subjective. I can definitely tell a big difference on a retina Ipad from a non-retina.
But when I was shopping for a Macbook, I spent a lot of time looking at the Macbook Pro's with retina, I ended up on a 13" MBA, and I think the display looks great. I have no regrets.
I couldn't see myself using an 11" MBA. But if I had to choose between that or an Ipad, I'd probably go with the 11" MBA - but most of my time on the computer is work stuff. If it was just casual browsing I'd probably think twice.
Ditto .
I had MBA 11 and I found it frustrating to get any serious work done due to small screen and low resolution.
Agree. If I were to get a laptop (God forbid) it would definitely be a small one. The only thing holding me back is the teeny screen, which is smaller than an iPad screen and the resolution of a slightly wider original iPad. Think about it! I would be interested in the nMB if it wasn't for the fact that it's a laptop and I prefer the touch interface, and the enormous price.
What makes you say that? I find the Apple bluetooth keyboard to be great, and just like the keyboard on the MBA (if there are differences other than having slightly more tilt, my fingers aren't finding them).
When paired with an Origami keyboard case, the ipad basically functions like a small laptop (one that runs iOS, of course).
http://store.apple.com/us/product/H6353ZM/A/incase-origami-workstation
I have tried twice to reduce my briefcase's weight by going to iPad. But basic salesman tools don't work well enough.
I also use the Apple Bluetooth Keyboard and find it moire than acceptable when I need to write long documents. I use a WingStand www.wingstand.com to connect the keyboard to the iPad and it works quite well.