I… actually agree with this. My
favorite weekend device happens to be the iPad Pro.
Using the likes of YouTube and many very specific apps trumps over the desktop counterparts (although some of that is purpose, the YouTube app could be checkboxed by Google to run right now in macOS).
Drawing and 3D sculpting apps are a bliss on iPad too, the Pencil Pro is truly unmatched I find, so I don’t look forward to use them in a multi screen desktop cramped with multiple windows and popups that fight for screen space (likely a bad habit of mine).
So, if those desktop experiences are any hint of what would happen to iPadOS, maybe they are correct by not slapping macOS on top right away and take the time to add the good points (flexibility in file systems, windows management, maybe add a way to load Mac .app files?, etc) while protecting the minimalistic streamlined nature of iPadOS (albeit yes, I agree it’s limited).
I also
kinda trust it way more… on an iPad I close nothing, I restart it never and it’s always snappy and ready. On macOS it isn’t bad at all, but I restart or turn it off once a week for good measure.
———
A personal recent iPad Pro usage attempt experience:
I think feature parity should happen at the each app’s level instead, recently I was doing a very simple ugly keynote file: a title, bullet points and screenshots (some basic real state fix ups thing). Decided to use the iPad… and honestly it felt like a drag.
- Adding a picture is annoying (no multi select in keynote insert), adding from photos to keynote requires a bit of finger gymnastics (multi select in photos then find your way back to keynote with all fingers there).
- Everything is too big since it’s made for bulky fingers.
- Then making a PDF from there happened spit a huge file and I couldn’t find a way to do the Preview’s app re-export optimized feature.
Had to finish on a laptop after all…
And I’m afraid that these issues wouldn’t be there if the keynote app was just the same or at least had the same features.
If they had just slapped macOS, increased the size of everything for touch friendliness, and made it convoluted to multi select and export optimized, etc then it would still be as annoying as it is right now but with a macOS front… for that example I don’t think it was iPadOS itself the problem.