Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I will admit I have not read every post in this thread.

I have a zany idea.

How about in the iPad options there being a list of say 3 or 4 different functions that switch can do.

And let the user decide (based on their needs) what the switch does.

No one setting will be right for everyone.

How about we push for that as an idea?

Give the user a choice.

YAY for Piggie! Yes, let's push for that idea! :D

http://www.apple.com/feedback/ipad.html
 
I may need to mute my iPad once or twice a month. I used the lock switch several times a week. I don't think this will be very useful.
Different strokes for different folks. :)

Personally, I hope that Apple sets this up as a system setting so the user can select which one works for them. Win-Win that way.
 
I confess to being too lazy to read 10 pages of posts. What on earth do people use orientation lock on the IPad for? I get it on the iPhone - if you aren't upright (e.g. if I wake up in the morning, and check the weather - I might want to use portrait mode even though I am lying horizontally on the bed).

But on the iPad - really??
 
I confess to being too lazy to read 10 pages of posts. What on earth do people use orientation lock on the IPad for? I get it on the iPhone - if you aren't upright (e.g. if I wake up in the morning, and check the weather - I might want to use portrait mode even though I am lying horizontally on the bed).

But on the iPad - really??

You are joking, right?
 
Not a fan of this change if it happens. I use the rotation lock switch a lot. It'll be a much larger pain if I have to fiddle around with the app-switcher UI to turn the rotation lock off and on. :(
 
No, I've had an iPad since the UK launch day (actually the day before) and have used orientation lock 0 times. Seriously, what do people use it for?

You use it to prevent the UI from rotating on you. :cool:

All the time, I'm showing stuff to my wife who's sitting, while I'm standing, or vice-versa, or I have the device lying on a flat surface (which makes it prone to inadvertent UI rotation), or am lying in bed using it, etc, etc. I use the switch constantly. Almost every time I use the device.

You can already silence the device by holding down the volume button. Removing the rotation lock and burying it in the app-switcher UI is a reduction in usability. Not a fan.
 
No, I've had an iPad since the UK launch day (actually the day before) and have used orientation lock 0 times. Seriously, what do people use it for?

To lock the orientation.

Seriously, it's a stupid question.

Furthermore, I read with the iPad in bed more than the iPhone as it's a better reading experience. Turning to my side requires orientation lock etc. I am of the opinion that it is actually more useful on the iPad than the iPhone, as even the lock screen rotates on the iPad.
 

LOL, I actually have a girlfriend and don't think she'd approve of that first thing in the morning. More a case of reading news articles and emails and so on. Checking twitter without it spinning around.

However, yes, I am sure it would be useful for porn - though I would be more likely to put the iPad somewhere and look at it, rather than change rotation mid-spank.
 
Because some developers may want to use the rotate gesture for something else. Some things need to be saved for the OS. Others for apps.

Screen orientation and position lock gesture(s) could be very different from object rotate gesture without being an inconsistency.
 
LOL, I actually have a girlfriend and don't think she'd approve of that first thing in the morning. More a case of reading news articles and emails and so on. Checking twitter without it spinning around.

However, yes, I am sure it would be useful for porn - though I would be more likely to put the iPad somewhere and look at it, rather than change rotation mid-spank.

LOL - y'all are funny.. :p

I use the rotation lock every few minutes -- when looking through long sequences of photos in the Camera roll, in Apple's Photos app. The reason is simple: as photos are imported to the iPad from a camera, many of them will not be oriented in the optimum viewing direction.

Even photos that have been previously rotated & organized into albums (within iPhoto, usually) can require that the iPad be oriented in a different direction. No matter what ya do, NOT ALL photos look best in portrait, and not all look best in landscape. So it commonly happens that I want the screen to be locked as I page through a sequence of images -- AND then, later, to be UNlocked, so that the screen can rotate to the other direction.

To be obliged to fiddle onscreen with the user interface to accomplish this obviously interrupts what I am looking at, and so creates a *total* loss of the workflow when looking through long sequences of images.

This same problem was described above, by forum member Night Spring, in great detail -- in relationship to reading and typing on the iPad.

Macwheels
 
However, yes, I am sure it would be useful for porn - though I would be more likely to put the iPad somewhere and look at it, rather than change rotation mid-spank.

Which is why I have a stand for mine ;)

But seriously, I don't use my switch more than a few times a day, yet I don't see a purpose for a mute switch on the iPad - it won't ring so as to offend, interrupt etc.
Unless I leave Skype on, but then it doesn't have vibration built in so I won't even know. I see the current state of affairs (3.2.2) as a good one.
If Apple chooses to change it - leave the user the chance, if not to configure, then to choose a setting!
 
Annoying change? Yes.
People saying get used to it: you have no idea how useful it was.
People saying that Apple should provide an option: HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA.


I'll just have to get used to it. Sucks? A bit. But the reason why it's going to be come mute is so you can mute any incoming rings to FaceTime on the next device.
 
This makes very little sense. Given the way an iPad is generally used and held, locking and unlocking the orientation with the switch is logical and easy. Absolutely everybody who uses an iPad will lock and unlock the orientation probably several times a day.

To devote an entire hardware switch to mute is ridiculous - mute can be achieved by just lowering the volume to zero with the rocker, and for myself I have my iPad on mute for days at a time and never need to adjust any volume. I don't imagine I'm the only one who uses an iPad this way.

+1 on this

if the ipad actually "rang" like the iphone, I could see it. Press-n-hold volume switch mutes the ipad anyway
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.