Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
4345DE65-2E28-446C-AF26-AF0D8E8372AE.gif


I've noticed on my 14 Pro that the previous app text on the top left does not always appear with an active island.
It does show if you pull down from the top.
Hopefully future iOS 16 updates resolve this. :rolleyes:
 
  • Like
Reactions: klasma
How does it behave in landscape? Tell us. Show us.

As for bright sunlight... DI is an illusion, which is part of its brilliance, but there's no getting away from physical hardware that's embedded in the screen. Can't really complain about that.
That’s wishful thinking… Apple along with other manufactures release smartphones annually because that’s the nature of the tech industry. And if you want fully baked products… why not wait until you personally think the product is ready to purchase.
Because they finally fixed issues that were created 4 years ago. And because battery life improves. And because the 13 pro took the worst photos ever with the watercolor processing. This 14 pro seems better so far. Many reasons ti upgrade yearly.
They still shouldn’t push new features until they are fully realized. And work faster to fix them.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: rileyes
Thanks, someone did show that the Icons on the DI do rotate, like the headphones one however I noticed on dave2d review other pop ups were not the DI expanding but a whole new land mass created :)

I understood that DI was trying to add consistency of some notifications but seems has created its own inconsistency

View attachment 2072572

Is this representative of bright sunlight and does 2000 nits make DI illusion worse ?

View attachment 2072579
I see what you mean about the inconsistency. I tried it with the audio playing in DI and rotated in Safari, and everything blacked out as described.

That sunlight image seems a little different than I’ve seen. Mostly the DI stays very black, and the sensors are about as visible as they are in the notch.

When using the phone I don’t notice the DI much more than I did the notch - it’s at the top while I’m doing something else, and I can access a few things there if needed.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SteveJUAE
And if you want fully baked products… why not wait until you personally think the product is ready to purchase.
Because that never happens, since they keep adding new semi-baked stuff and don’t fix many issues from previous years. It’s a perpetual work in progress.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rileyes and idktbh
I think the Island is a neat feature built around hardware modules. It’s not perfect but better than the notch.

To address some of the questions here, in semi-bright light, the pill and hole punch are fairly obvious but it’s not distracting. Also depends on the angle.

For me, the most distracting aspect of the island is the outline around it when using dark mode. I set my phone to always use dark mode so I see this often. Essentially, the Island gets a glowing effect to needlessly separate it from the status bar.

AE15A635-1478-4A8B-B57E-D1F5E1F229F1.jpeg
 
Because that never happens, since they keep adding new semi-baked stuff and don’t fix many issues from previous years. It’s a perpetual work in progress.
Yeah, they keep adding features. But I’ll like to think next year Dynamic Island will be a complete thought… it was introduced this year. With Apple, there’s the S years where the features have a clear understanding of its use cases and devs get more accumulate to the hardware.
 
Yeah, they keep adding features. But I’ll like to think next year Dynamic Island will be a complete thought… it was introduced this year. With Apple, there’s the S years where the features have a clear understanding of its use cases and devs get more accumulate to the hardware.
I wouldn’t be so sure. Notifications for example are still a mess after I don’t know how many years.
 
  • Love
Reactions: CoMoMacUser
I wouldn’t be so sure. Notifications for example are still a mess after I don’t know how many years.
Notifications a mess? How so? I’m an Android user now… but when I had an iPhone there was never any issues with notifications.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: rileyes
Even though I just got a last year model, makes me want to get the 14 pro, but I shall wait for the 15 when all the kinks are worked out.
 
Notifications a mess? How so? I’m an Android user now… but when I had an iPhone there was never any issues with notifications.
See here for example: https://forums.macrumors.com/threads/lock-screen-notification-hell-merged.2358398/
This had been reported since Beta 1 and has remained unfixed.

In iOS 15 and earlier, notifications already behaved non-intuitively. A personal pet peeve is that push notifications are not correlated with the respective app state. E.g., when I read a message in some IM app for which a push notification was previously sent, then the notification still stays around and I have to dismiss it separately, although the app knows that I already read the notified message. It seems to be a protocol limitation that apps cannot dismiss their own notifications when the reason for the notification has become obsolete. That’s just very inconvenient. Yet another issue is that there is no notification history. Once you’ve dismissed a notification or a group of notifications, which sometimes can happen by accident, there’s no way to access them in a history.
 
Last edited:
So much potential. Terrible initial implementation.
Most notifications dont need to expand to a fat dynamic notification. Ex: Shortcuts.
Fat dynamic notifications block time.
When you receive a phone call, sometimes you want to glance at the time, but its blocked.
Tap status bar to scroll back to the top is now a wonky mess.
Island now makes notification center and control center access even smaller and more difficult.
Face id doesnt need to be a popped out square, just give us a small animation inside dynamic island.

Island cuts in to youtube videos in portrait and landscape.
The status bar is just too big now.
If it going to be big and fat, let us add other stuff to status bar and customize.

Tap for widget, long press for app would be better.

Let us make something permanently stay in the island, like apple music player or podcast, for quick access to an app. Or some permanent info in there, day & date maybe. Anything really.

I get it’s early its implementation, but lets not eait 4 years until it’s fixed like everything else apple does.

We want day 1 full baked products, not half.

tell me you're a "glass half empty" kind of person without telling me -_-

time to ignore the comments on this site for another year.
 
See here for example: https://forums.macrumors.com/threads/lock-screen-notification-hell-merged.2358398/
This had been reported since Beta 1 and has remained unfixed.
Tbf, this is a situation where Apple has designed notifications differently where users have to adjust to the new change.

In iOS 15 and earlier, notifications already behaved non-intuitively. A personal pet peeve is that push notifications are not correlated with the respective app state. E.g., when I read a message in some IM app for which a push notification was previously sent, then the notification still stays around and I have to dismiss it separately, although the app knows that I already read the notified message. It seems to be a protocol limitation that apps cannot dismiss their own notifications when the reason for the notification has become obsolete. That’s just very inconvenient.
Maybe it’s with 3rd party apps. But I personally never had any issues with this… since I mainly use Message or Mail app and it will delete the push notification when I read it in that particular app.

Yet another issue is that there is no notification history. Once you’ve dismissed a notification or a group of notifications, which sometimes can happen by accident, there’s no way to access them in a history.
And this is considered a mess? There’s notification history on Android and I don’t use it.
 
A2A2600F-9A54-4776-B6DD-6B121CD6CFB2.png
I love this use case. Phone mounted on vent, maps & music for non car play cars
 
Please someone explain why this exists?

The hardware is WORSE than the notch as it uses up more screen real estate.

I literally see no benefit hardware wise, it’s objectively worse for users, and they could have done stuff in software with black background notifications around the notch.

They could have expanded the notch on both sides into a “dynamic bar” or maybe even call it the “Touch Bar.”
 
My only question on any overbearing feature like this is can you 100% disable it?
 
Please someone explain why this exists?

The hardware is WORSE than the notch as it uses up more screen real estate.

I literally see no benefit hardware wise, it’s objectively worse for users, and they could have done stuff in software with black background notifications around the notch.

They could have expanded the notch on both sides into a “dynamic bar” or maybe even call it the “Touch Bar.”
Because with Notch 1.0, the official party line was that we love the notch. Remember, they even published guidelines that apps shouldn’t do anything to try to hide the notch. Yet surprisingly, people continued to hate having a giant cutout on their screen. So Party Line 2.0 is to try to hide Notch 2.0. And the strategy is to act like it’s an amazing new “feature”. And MacRumors is devoting A LOT of content to help facilitate that narrative.
 
  • Like
Reactions: josehill
xbox did it 2005….

PerfectActualKitfox-size_restricted.gif
This comment is extremely underrated and should have more likes, it's hilarious and somewhat true. You know what they say, the best idea is a stolen idea.

And before you go responding with, Android did this, Google did that, windows copied this... squawk, squawk, squawk! I get it. I know. They all do it. Doesn't make the comment any less funny.

Thanks for making me laugh today Muzzakus!
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.