SUCCESS!
First, the hardware: An original iPhone that was received from Apple as a replacement in mid 2011. (The 'battery replacement' program, $70 basically got you a factory refurbished version of whatever you were turning in.) Obviously it came with the latest iPhone OS 3.1.3 with the latest boot loader and modem firmware.
Then, the software: Parallels running Windows XP with iTunes 7.5.0.20; iBrickr 0.91, and "ZiPhone_patched_by_kIREmK_04.05.04_G"
I had tried in the past and gotten it down to some variation of iPhone OS 2, but never below.
Following the directions at
http://sonnydickson.com/60921917 I was just able to get it to 1.1.4. This required *MANY* attempts, many restores, many DFU modes, many runs of iBrickr and ZiPhone. In the end, a restore to 1.1.4 followed by a ZiPhone -a did it. (I had it in various "activate now" states before at 1.1.1 and 1.1.4, but couldn't get it to activate until just now.)
Now I'm trying to go back to 1.1.1 (which is where you have to be to get to 1.0.2.) I'll probably stop at 1.0.2 since it is functionally identical to 1.0, only with bug fixes.
Also, when I'm done, I'll report on the other aspect of this phone: It has been officially unlocked by AT&T. It worked fine on T-Mobile officially, non-jailbroken, not hack-unlocked after the AT&T unlock, while on iOS 3.1.3. I wonder if it will keep the factory unlock on iPhone OS 1.x? (Which was *NEVER* available on any carrier other than AT&T officially in the US; although it was available in France unlocked.)
Edit: Downgraded to 1.1.1, downgraded baseband with ZiPhone, then hacktivated with ZiPhone. Recognizes T-Mobile SIM, although I have a
really bad signal right here, so can't test-call. (My unlocked 3G that works fine elsewhere on T-Mobile likewise has signal issues where I am right now.)
Edit 2: Attempted the 1.0.2 downgrade, and I'm stuck in a loop, I can enter DFU mode, but flashing fails and it enters "plain recovery" mode. When I try to use iBrickr to get out of recovery mode, the phone hangs. I suppose I'll have to re-flash 1.1.1 and just stay there.