Sidebar Sidebar
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

iPhone 3G Hard Case That Doesn't Scratch

Macman756

Macman756

macrumors 6502a
Original poster
Sep 24, 2008
544
0
Atlanta, GA
Hey guys,

I'm looking for a case for my iPhone 3G that won't scratch. On all my iPods I've had a skin, but I really don't want that on my phone. I think the plastic scratches easier than the aluminum iPhone EDGE. So what brand or model hard case doesn't scratch? Thank
 
Any idea what this means techincally?

"*Please note this item is not intended to be used with Screen Protectors or Clear Armor."

So if I have a screen protector then I can't use this case?
 
Rat-Boy said:
Any idea what this means techincally?

"*Please note this item is not intended to be used with Screen Protectors or Clear Armor."

So if I have a screen protector then I can't use this case?
Click to expand...

Yep, you have to take the screen protector off when using that kind of case.
 
Mikey B said:
Yep, you have to take the screen protector off when using that kind of case.
Click to expand...

Yea, I think I posted that question a bit too fast.

It appears that this case has it's own screen protector and I guess two screen protectors would probably cause your finger touches to not register.

I might consider this case. I have been through three that I don't like and can't seem to find one I do like.
 
Jonnyfive said:
those look like really slick cases.

I know that the griffen cases scratch! They angered me!
Click to expand...

I have the Case Mate clear case.

I'm not really too fond of them. Yes, they include a plastic cover that protects the screen but, the plastic cover is not really a thick plastic. More of a thin plastic that has a rubbery feel. So in case of a drop, I doubt it'll do much.

The case is rather bulky and after about a weeks worth, you'll find massive amounts of lint trapped in the case. So every week or so, you'll find yourself taking the case apart and clearing out the junk inside.

But, the worst part of the case is that IT WILL SCRATCH THE BACK OF YOUR PHONE. The back of the plastic case has a small groove that unfortunately slightly digs into the back of your phone when taking the case off. After numerous times of taking off the case to clean it, it will leave a small but rather noticeable cut in the back of the phone.

To remedy the situation, I've put a small folded up paper in the exact spot where the case cuts in the phone.

I'm really looking for another clear hard case that covers the entire phone, including the front and remains lint free. Not just some dinky film that slips over the face of the phone. Until then, this bootleg method will have to do.
 
I've used the Switcheasy Capsule Rebel case on my 3g iphone and I love it. They offer 3 or 4 great cases that provide very nice protection. You can see the selection they offer for the device at www.switcheasy.com.
 
Otterbox defender, not a true hard case but a hard case with a silicone sleeve over it, insanely protective and worth every penny
 
Okay, I know this thread is in the wrong forum and if the mods want to move it, well, they should.

But I thought I would post this here.

I am one who is now no his 4th case for the iPhone 3G because I can't find one I like.

So a few days ago, I bought the Case Mate clear case.

I have to say, there are positives and negatives:

Positives:

1) Access to all ports.

2) Adequate protection for the phone including the screen and buttons.

Negatives:

1) A nightmare to get the case off at first. (I have only taken it off twice due to not cleaning the phone good enough before putting it in. I am sure, once it is taken off a bunch of times, it will get easier.)

2) This case is a nightmare if you are one that carries your phone in your pocket. As someone said above, lint and dust will get under the screen protector and then you have to take the case off.

3) When gripping the phone, it sounds a little "rickety" if you will.

So, if you think you like this case or are considering getting it:

1) Only get it if you carry your iPhone on a hip case on your belt or attached to your purse. I find that since I do this, I get a LOT less lint and dust on my phone (and under the built in screen protector) than when it is in your pocket.

2) I know what the web site says, but I ignored it, and installed this case with another screen protection film on the phone. I have experienced no negative effects of having the 2nd screen protector under the phone and have in fact, seen a positive of it.

Much like when you put one of those window cling things on your car's back window, you can get kind of air bubbles under the case's screen protector if you put the case on with nothing else. I think this is because the screen protector of the case hovers a millimeter or less over the screen and doesn't actually cling to the screen. (I saw one on a phone at the AT T store and this almost caused me to not buy the case.)

But with my anti-glare screen protector already on the phone, it seems to help this not to happen. I am guessing that is because the gap between the case's screen protector and the phone screen is taken up by the existing screen protector.

And the touch screen still works flawlessly.

So there is my review of the Case Mate Naked Case for the 3G.

Hope someone find this helpful...
 
From personal experience, stay far far away from the Griffin Elan Form. I am very pleased with the Incase Slider. It has little rubber tracks keeping it from the surface of the case (no scratches), fits very well, feels good, comes in a few colors, and provides overall great protection.
 
dwcliff said:
I've used the Switcheasy Capsule Rebel case on my 3g iphone and I love it. They offer 3 or 4 great cases that provide very nice protection. You can see the selection they offer for the device at www.switcheasy.com.
Click to expand...

I need a case for my iphone as well

and since you brought this up, i just checked it out and I think i like this one a lot, especially the rebel serpent.. but i got one question here- im wondering if this one covers(protects) the screen? or it is being protected by 2 of those anti glare screen guards that comes with the kit?

I am not sure if the screen is protected enough by the guards? I always have liked the idea of the actual case covering the screen like case mate?

would appreciate it if you could fill me in on this one thanks!
 
Macman756 said:
Hey guys,

I'm looking for a case for my iPhone 3G that won't scratch. On all my iPods I've had a skin, but I really don't want that on my phone. I think the plastic scratches easier than the aluminum iPhone EDGE. So what brand or model hard case doesn't scratch? Thank
Click to expand...

really?
i felt like the aluminum scratched WAY too easily

but this looks promising
http://www.speckproducts.com/products/candyshell/iphone-3g/162
great looks, and rubber inside to cushion the phone
 
Well, after my long review of the Case Mate case, I ended up taking it back and going with the Incase Slider.

Reason?

Exactly what someone else posted.

The Case Mate, on the surface, sounds cool. It completely covers the phone.

Well, here is the problem:

1) The screen protection is not much harder or more protective than the screen films you can buy.

2) The Lint factor. Stuff gets under that screen protector through the holes for the ear speaker, connector and home button. Then, your only choice is to take the phone out to clean it. VERY annoying.

So I took it back and got the Incase Slider instead. I am happy with it so far, though on mine, the gap between the two pieces is noticeable in my hand.
 
You'd be surprised at how scratch resistant the plastic really is on the iPhone 3G. I have hardly any scratches on it and I don't use a case. I just worry about CRACKS!
 
its not the case that scratches the phone, its what gets in the case that scratches the iphone, every case is vonrable to this as they have certain openings for camera, power, volume, etc buttons, access points.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.
Top Bottom
Back