Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

uberamd

macrumors 68030
Original poster
May 26, 2009
2,785
2
Minnesota
I ran some very nonscientific tests with my iPhone 3G S, iPhone 3G, and iPod Touch 1G using the same wireless network. I quickly discovered that the hardware enhancements in the 3G S gave it an undeniable edge in the wireless performance. It was interesting to see first hand the difference the hardware makes in wireless performance.

Each device was running 3.0 and I took the best result out of 5 tests for each device. Remember that speed is measured in Mbps (megabits per second) not MB/sec (megabytes per second) meaning 8 Mbps = 1 MB/sec.

iPod Touch 1st Generation

ipod1g.png


iPhone 3G

iphone3g.png


iPhone 3G S

iphone3gs1.png
 
Makes perfect sense to me. The iPhone 3G was always lacking in the internet speed department, even over wifi!! The only limiting factor was the processing power and ram of the device. I haven't had time to use my 3G S over wifi extensively but I'm glad to see this is the case!!
 
Makes perfect sense to me. The iPhone 3G was always lacking in the internet speed department, even over wifi!! The only limiting factor was the processing power and ram of the device. I haven't had time to use my 3G S over wifi extensively but I'm glad to see this is the case!!

Yeah exactly. And while its not going to be noticeable for everyone (those who have under 7Mbps network connections) it should be pointed out that the Speedtest app stalls and chokes at times on the iPod Touch and 3G, however the entire length of the test it was smooth for the 3G S. The extra processing power and ram are making a big difference.
 
I ran some very nonscientific tests with my iPhone 3G S, iPhone 3G, and iPod Touch 1G using the same wireless network. I quickly discovered that the hardware enhancements in the 3G S gave it an undeniable edge in the wireless performance. It was interesting to see first hand the difference the hardware makes in wireless performance.

Each device was running 3.0 and I took the best result out of 5 tests for each device. Remember that speed is measured in Mbps (megabits per second) not MB/sec (megabytes per second) meaning 8 Mbps = 1 MB/sec.

iPod Touch 1st Generation

ipod1g.png


iPhone 3G

iphone3g.png


iPhone 3G S

iphone3gs1.png

I wish I could even come close to those!

Mine dl at a max of 4mb
upload .89 mb.

ATT DSL, with 6.5 meg business DSL. This is the fastest I can even purchase from my provider at my office, and home.

Another words, I cannot even meet half of the speed you show, you're lucky friend.
 
I wish I could even come close to those!

Mine dl at a max of 4mb
upload .89 mb.

ATT DSL, with 6.5 meg business DSL. This is the fastest I can even purchase from my provider at my office, and home.

Another words, I cannot even meet half of the speed you show, you're lucky friend.

To put it in perspective, on the same network using my PowerMac G5 over wired (vs wireless) I get

speed1.png


And on wireless using the PowerMac G5 I get

speed2.png


So as you can see, the wifi on the handheld devices matches and outperforms the PowerMac G5 on wireless, but obviously pales in comparison to the PowerMac G5 over ethernet.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.