Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Kal525

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Jun 17, 2009
28
0
Let me say one thing before I go on - this is a great phone. It feels great, it functions great, and it looks great... except for one thing - It is NOT scratch resistant.

I know people probably won't be excited to hear this; I definitely wasn't excited to discover it. But after just 2 days of babying my iPhone 4 I have discovered 2 scuff-like scratches on the back. Now when I say "babying" I mean only resting the phone on felt, carrying it around in a microfiber bag, and generally handling it as delicately as possible. I have no idea how these scratches are even possible given how carefully I was handling the phone, but I can't deny the facts.

I've attached a few images using a macro lens to show the damage up close so you can see and evaluate for yourselves. I should also add that the scratches become more visible if they have fingerprints and finger oil on them (the photos show them in a clean state).

Mild sharpening and contrast enhancements:

attachment.php


Significant tonal contrast enhancement:

attachment.php


The results should speak for themselves. Upon taking these photos I also noticed that the back of the iPhone 4 is not very uniform. It looks almost like an imperfectly machined surface rather than smooth glass. This of course may be because of the proximity of the lens to the phone, but it still leads me to believe that those of us who were thinking about keeping the phone "naked" and trusting in the scratch-proof claim put forth by Apple should think twice before doing so. It almost appears as though there is some coating over the glass which itself is what might be scratch prone.

So... is this the end of the world? Certainly not, but I figured I'd post to clear up some of the confusion that I've seen about how scratch-proof the iPhone really is. It clearly does not take throwing it against a wall or dropping it on the floor for it to get scratched. Take this advice for what it's worth and in the end remember one thing - it's just a phone :)
 

Attachments

  • iPhone4Scratch.jpg
    iPhone4Scratch.jpg
    750.6 KB · Views: 4,900
  • iPhone4Scratch_Enhanced.jpg
    iPhone4Scratch_Enhanced.jpg
    927.1 KB · Views: 4,836
Ouch.. those are brutal.

Has there been any confirmation on whether or not Apple is using Gorilla glass on the back? Reports say they are using it on the front but I don't even know if that has been confirmed.
 
What?! How in the world did you do this?

I can tell you i've put mine in my pocket bare for over 24 hours now, nothing like this.

Are you sure you even took off the plastic cover on this thing? It looks like you didn't.
 
There is no way microfiber or human flesh could cause abrasions on glass like that. Either someone (or a pet) did something to your iphone when you weren't looking, or you sleepwalked with it! Sucks though.
 
What?! How in the world did you do this?

I can tell you i've put mine in my pocket bare for over 24 hours now, nothing like this.

Are you sure you even took off the plastic cover on this thing? It looks like you didn't.

yeah good point! The whole back of that phone looks effed up! Because i've had mine in my pocket now too and the only scratches i have are little scuffs on the camera lens - which totally unaffects the camera anyway.
 
Haha - plastic still on? Really guys? The plastic is not still on, I don't have pets, and I do not sleep walk. Keep in mind that these scratches are barely visible except under the right light. I used a macro lens with very bright light and took the photo at an angle which would reveal the scratches. The point was to show the material of the iphone backing up close so as to gain a better understanding of what the surface actually looks like when scrutinized. It looks nowhere near as bad in practice. The main point still remains - the back of the iPhone 4 scratches easily, even if it may not be immediately visible to the naked eye. My worry is that over time the phone will be more likely to accumulate visible scratches. Take my analysis for what it's worth and make your own conclusions. I've tried to be as objective as possible.
 
Haha - plastic still on? Really guys? The plastic is not still on, I don't have pets, and I do not sleep walk. Keep in mind that these scratches are barely visible except under the right light. I used a macro lens with very bright light and took the photo at an angle which would reveal the scratches. The point was to show the material of the iphone backing up close so as to gain a better understanding of what the surface actually looks like when scrutinized. It looks nowhere near as bad in practice. The main point still remains - the back of the iPhone 4 scratches easily, even if it may not be immediately visible to the naked eye. My worry is that over time the phone will be more likely to accumulate visible scratches. Take my analysis for what it's worth and make your own conclusions. I've tried to be as objective as possible.

"Barely visible except under the right light" and people are calling it "brutal"?

Hey, I have this invisible monkey who bothers me but only on Wednesdays and when I'm facing a North-Northeasterly direction. He doesn't actually do anything to me. He just stands there. He's invisible... so, technically, I can see right through him and he doesn't affect anything. But GOD why can't this effin' monkey leave me alone.
 
Haha - plastic still on? Really guys? The plastic is not still on, I don't have pets, and I do not sleep walk. Keep in mind that these scratches are barely visible except under the right light. I used a macro lens with very bright light and took the photo at an angle which would reveal the scratches. The point was to show the material of the iphone backing up close so as to gain a better understanding of what the surface actually looks like when scrutinized. It looks nowhere near as bad in practice. The main point still remains - the back of the iPhone 4 scratches easily, even if it may not be immediately visible to the naked eye. My worry is that over time the phone will be more likely to accumulate visible scratches. Take my analysis for what it's worth and make your own conclusions. I've tried to be as objective as possible.


Please give us more photos, different angles, different lights etc... Also, don't enhance the photos.
 
"Barely visible except under the right light" and people are calling it "brutal"?

Hey, I have this invisible monkey who bothers me but only on Wednesdays and when I'm facing a North-Northeasterly direction. He doesn't actually do anything to me. He just stands there. He's invisible... so, technically, I can see right through him and he doesn't affect anything. But GOD why can't this effin' monkey leave me alone.

That might be the best forum post I've ever read.

Applause.gif



Something rubbed against that phone, cloth and micro fiber would not do that.
 
think of it this way...you truly have a unique iPhone unlike anyone else in the universe. The grains are aligned in a way that is only unique to yours, and yours alone. No one can replicate the same depth of scratches and or style as yours.



hey post pics of the cloth you used to wipe it with.

was it bounty?
 
I have scratched mine already on a piece of plastic in my car. Nowhere near as brutal as yours, but still disappointing.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.