I'm pretty sure if Jony Ivy handed my iPhone to Steve Jobs and said "ok here's your phone," Jobs would return it based on this issue. I'd sorta like mine replaced as well. But seriously, tell me if this is just too fine a point. My SIM tray protrudes from the case a little bit on one side. You can see it visually, but running your finger over it it's quite obvious. Would you keep your iPhone if it had this defect? Or would you ask for a replacement?