Sidebar Sidebar
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

iPhone 5 screen crack without dropping?

There is comparable insurance available other than Apple Care that includes accidental damage. And you get a new phone not a refurbished one.
 
Oui said:
I'm calling BS.
Click to expand...

You can call what you want. All I know is this crack came from out of the blue.

----------
rogershaffer1 said:
There is comparable insurance available other than Apple Care that includes accidental damage. And you get a new phone not a refurbished one.
Click to expand...

I have never had any issues. My phones are always scratchless /crackless and that's how I sell them for top dollar to buy the next model. After this mess, I may look into it. I just could not see getting any insurance since I never really have my phone for long because I always get the next model. *sighs*
 
Update!

At the Apple store now. The genius rep said, before I even explained, that CLEARLY I did not drop my phone. I got it replaced for free. :) I am happy!!!
 
Well done - that's good news :)

That just proves that, providing you are honest and have a genuine problem, service from Apple is second to none.
 
Single hairline cracks are covered under your warranty....if an FRS or Genius tries to tell you otherwise, tell them to look at their own documentation.
 
rw3 said:
Single hairline cracks are covered under your warranty....if an FRS or Genius tries to tell you otherwise, tell them to look at their own documentation.
Click to expand...

Where is this in the documentation? Cracks are usually signs of misuse, which the warranty documentation clearly states is not covered.
 
AFDoc said:
You're comparing a sunroof.... something that is much larger, secured in a much different way, has way different stresses placed upon it to the glass in a cell phone...... yeah, ok.
Click to expand...

My point was that during assembly or manufacturing a microscopic nick or whatever could have occurred in the glass causing it to weaken. Apparently that's too much for you to grasp.
 
rw3 said:
Go look at my Public Profile and what my occupation is.....
Click to expand...

For some reason, the forum won't show me the "about me" section on your profile. I'm assuming you're a genius. Aren't apple employees not allowed to have any accounts on here?A friend of mine who is an apple store employee was forced to shut down his apple blog because he got a job at the apple store. He also says it is forbidden to use this website.
 
Maybe you had keys in your bockets that banged up against the screen. I always try to keep my keys and phone in seperate pockets.
 
Heck when I bought my iPhone 5 at the apple store it was cracked in the box anythings possible
 
itjw said:
Bravo. You found a genius willing to gift you a free phone. Certainly you wouldn't have faulted him if they chose not to believe your story, because obviously (and you can call reality negativity all you want) not many people here believe you had absolutely nothing to do with it.

Apple is the nicest company out there with regards to tech returns.

Sometimes they'll replace a phone that people ADMIT to dropping just because they are in that mood. Sometimes they insist on the $229.

Just because they replaced your phone doesn't mean anyone that had questions about how it really happened were wrong or weren't contributing to your thread, we just weren't telling you what you wanted to hear.

You got lucky. Next time you drop it, sit on it, hit it with something... whatever REALLY happened you might not be.
Click to expand...

This one guy works/worked for Apple. He was told to believe any story that suggested the damage was covered, even if the story was obviously wrong.
 
rw3 said:
Single hairline cracks are covered under your warranty....if an FRS or Genius tries to tell you otherwise, tell them to look at their own documentation.
Click to expand...

Only if there is no impact mark. I.e. if you drop it, there's a tiny circular crack in the middle with 2 hairlines coming off of it, that's not covered.

Also, the 3G/3GS was an exception - single hairline cracks are only covered if they form a V shape from the receiver, or from the home button to the base of the screen.
 
damie45 said:
What I've noticed on these forums, is that as soon as someone report a problem w their product, there r a number of people that will accuse them of lying. I like apple products, but I'm not going to accuse someone of lying just because my product is working fine. Sometimes I think these people r hired by the manufacturers. I see the same on almost every forum I visits, which r mainly tech and car forums.
Click to expand...

When people make claims which have no crediibility, people let them know the claim is not beleivable. Phones don't just break all by themselves. It's not a credible claim. I'm glad she got her phone replaced for free, but I don't believe her story for a moment. It's reason and logic.
 
Rocko1 said:
Love the naysayers who will argue you to the death that you are 100% at fault for all issues with their beloved iPhone. Their voids must be deep and wide.
Click to expand...

Glass doesn't crack itself without any form of abuse. You do realise that a drop, knock or whatever can weaken it, causing it spontaneously crack weeks or months later. If the phone can survive shipping from China, the glass was/is fine when bought.

Just because it's cracked when it was in your pocket, doesn't mean it wasn't the owner's fault. I spent roughly 2 years servicing iPhones, and with the exception of the receiver/home button ones I mentioned above, I never saw a "mysterious self cracking" phone that, under inspection with a magnifying glass, didn't have a minor dent, chip or impact mark in a related place to the crack. It doesn't happen.
 
s15119 said:
When people make claims which have no crediibility, people let them know the claim is not beleivable. Phones don't just break all by themselves. It's not a credible claim. I'm glad she got her phone replaced for free, but I don't believe her story for a moment. It's reason and logic.
Click to expand...

Right. Where in your logical mind is it 100% impossible to have manufacturing flaws? All defects in glass are user error? This is illogical. :rolleyes:
 
Rocko1 said:
Right. Where in your logical mind is it 100% impossible to have manufacturing flaws? All defects in glass are user error? This is illogical. :rolleyes:
Click to expand...

If there was a manufacturing defect in glass that thin - it would never make it through the shipping process from China without cracking in the box, and would therefore be cracked out of the box - thus making cracking spontaneously in your pocket due to some manufacturing fault impossible.
 
bma said:
If there was a manufacturing defect in glass that thin - it would never make it through the shipping process from China without cracking in the box, and would be cracked out of the box.
Click to expand...

You are ill informed. The glass has a metal frame attached that adds stress. The crack was at the weakest point and followed the path of least resistance. Spontaneous glass breakage can and does occur for a multitude of reasons.

----------
bma said:
I never saw a "mysterious self cracking" phone that, under inspection with a magnifying glass, didn't have a minor dent, chip or impact mark in a related place to the crack.
Click to expand...

Oh well that proves it. You have not seen it. Case closed. :rolleyes:
 
Just from ur wording in ur OP I am almost 100% certain that u dropped it. No one would ever say "I didnt drop the phone because the bezel and chamfered edge are not damaged". You'd say simply "I didnt drop my phone".
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.
Top Bottom
Back