Hey MacRumors, I got my iPhone 5 on Sept. 28 and exchanged it 5 on Oct. 1st because it was scuffed out of the box and got a replacement from the Apple Store. I asked the Genius if I may return it if I accept the replacement and he said no. I accepted the replacement iPhone 5 which came from a white box and there was no issues cosmetically. But after 3 days of use, the home button is not working. I was able to use it a few hours ago but now the home button is dead. It might work randomly after 100 clicks but I tried it so many times by pressing lightly and adding pressure but it still wouldn't function. The home button was great on the first iPhone I got but this replacement is malfunctioning. My question is, will Apple Store let me replace/return it? And to the users who also have this problem, please tell me about your issue. As much as I like Apple products, I'm starting to be discouraged of getting an iPhone 5. Maybe this is happening because it is an early production unit though. Thanks!