My 7+ suffered the same fate.
I cited the advertisement of the phone in the rain, and a manager overrode the repair to replace my phone for free.
As always with the genius bar, YMMV, but I was polite and firm, and left them with no choice.
Firm and polite will only take you so far. Every Apple Store experience or repair service will vary as mentioned. It all depends on who you talk to, willingness and overall attitude of the Advisor (Or Corporate management) that investigates your case. I think everyone's experience will vary pending a case by case basis, but leaving Apple 'With No choice' isn't always going to achieve the outcome someone desires.
What it really comes down to is a company that cares about the customer Satisfaction, not the customer who decides what the end decision will be. (Which I'm not referring to necessarily your experience.) Apple goes to Great lengths to work with customer and most companies are limited in what they will offer to assist a customer.
There is a reason Apple's customer service is highly rated, even if it's the outcome that doesn't always work out in someone's situation. I believe Apple is a two fold company, they make great products and they have great customer service to back the products they manufacture.
Last edited: