iPhone advice please

MacBH928

macrumors 68040
Original poster
May 17, 2008
3,906
1,409
Hello,
I am looking for iPhone advice, I have waited long to purchase this device but I got a couple of questions

1) How serious is the antenna issue? I got a feeling that people are way over-reacting. I didn't use one myself so I can't tell. If the issue is just to not put your finger over that tiny crack on the side of the phone, I guess I can easily do that not to mention I am buying a bumper anyways. Or is it serious?

2) One of the main reason I am buying an iPhone is that I want to watch movies on my tv with it, and as far as I know, there is only one product that allows you to do this:
http://www.amazon.com/Apple-Compone...1?ie=UTF8&s=electronics&qid=1280405387&sr=8-1

3) I want the iphone for its apps and media mobility, am not into talking too much, would an ipod touch be a better choice especially considering the high price difference? When will the new ipod touches going to be out?

4)Steve Jobs mentioned that the free bumpers is just a temporary solution up until september, which is scaring me, does that mean a fixed iphone 4 is in the making after september?

5) Can any one in the UK confirm if the iPhones from the Apple store over there are unlocked? A friend of mine bought one from the Apple store in London and came back here to asia , he popped in the cell phone chip and it worked no extra work other than cutting the the chip itself to fit in.

thanks
 

maflynn

Moderator
Staff member
May 3, 2009
66,371
32,969
Boston
1) How serious is the antenna issue? I got a feeling that people are way over-reacting. I didn't use one myself so I can't tell. If the issue is just to not put your finger over that tiny crack on the side of the phone, I guess I can easily do that not to mention I am buying a bumper anyways. Or is it serious?
it depends on who you ask. My wife who owns an IP4 and uses her left hand to hold the phone has no antenna problems. She is dealing with the proximity sensor issue, and that's probably bugging her and many more then the antenna problem. Many folks believe that it will be corrected with a software fix.

3) I want the iphone for its apps and media mobility, am not into talking too much, would an ipod touch be a better choice especially considering the high price difference? When will the new ipod touches going to be out?
Would an iPad be a better option?

4)Steve Jobs mentioned that the free bumpers is just a temporary solution up until september, which is scaring me, does that mean a fixed iphone 4 is in the making after september?
The antenna issue is a design issue, there can be no other fix to existing phones aside from using a case. No other fix will be coming for owners.
 
Comment

esadb

macrumors 65816
Nov 29, 2008
1,184
0
Hello,
I am looking for iPhone advice, I have waited long to purchase this device but I got a couple of questions

1) How serious is the antenna issue? I got a feeling that people are way over-reacting. I didn't use one myself so I can't tell. If the issue is just to not put your finger over that tiny crack on the side of the phone, I guess I can easily do that not to mention I am buying a bumper anyways. Or is it serious?

2) One of the main reason I am buying an iPhone is that I want to watch movies on my tv with it, and as far as I know, there is only one product that allows you to do this:
http://www.amazon.com/Apple-Compone...1?ie=UTF8&s=electronics&qid=1280405387&sr=8-1

3) I want the iphone for its apps and media mobility, am not into talking too much, would an ipod touch be a better choice especially considering the high price difference? When will the new ipod touches going to be out?

4)Steve Jobs mentioned that the free bumpers is just a temporary solution up until september, which is scaring me, does that mean a fixed iphone 4 is in the making after september?

5) Can any one in the UK confirm if the iPhones from the Apple store over there are unlocked? A friend of mine bought one from the Apple store in London and came back here to asia , he popped in the cell phone chip and it worked no extra work other than cutting the the chip itself to fit in.

thanks

1) I would ignore the antenna issue, everyone is complaining about it yet they buy the iphone4. :confused:

2) Whole iPhone -> TV ordeal i dont know.. Why not just get a Western Digital Media Player? Its actually meant for that and works quite well.

3) If that is the case yes get a iPOD touch! Why would you spend 50-60$/month if you dont use it for talking purposes? And with the money saved you can buy that WD Media player.

4) No "fixed" iphone4 will be released. You know how much work it would take to implement a fix and release it in September and all the fuss they would cause with people? they might not necessarily change much for next summer.. Look at the 3G and 3GS..

5) Yes buying a iPhone straight from APPLE will get it factory unlocked. That's why your paying $700.
 
Comment

MacBH928

macrumors 68040
Original poster
May 17, 2008
3,906
1,409
3) If that is the case yes get a iPOD touch! Why would you spend 50-60$/month if you dont use it for talking purposes? And with the money saved you can buy that WD Media player.
I am not paying $50-$60 , I am over-seas and I will pay full $700 for it to be unlocked.

If any one can direct me to an ipod touch vs iphone review I'll appreciate it.
I am not sure if the only difference is being able to send sms and make calls. There is an almost $500 difference between unlocked iphone and ipod touch.

As for the WD media player, thats an option

but why get a WD media player, ipod, a cell phone , when u can have all 3 devices in one? less clutter , and I am guessing cheaper?

I am an apple guy, but would any one recommend looking at an iphone alternative such as the droid?
It might be cheaper, work international, no micro-sim necessary...
I am really a noob when it comes to cell phones
 
Comment

esadb

macrumors 65816
Nov 29, 2008
1,184
0
I am not paying $50-$60 , I am over-seas and I will pay full $700 for it to be unlocked.

If any one can direct me to an ipod touch vs iphone review I'll appreciate it.
I am not sure if the only difference is being able to send sms and make calls. There is an almost $500 difference between unlocked iphone and ipod touch.

As for the WD media player, thats an option

but why get a WD media player, ipod, a cell phone , when u can have all 3 devices in one? less clutter , and I am guessing cheaper?

I am an apple guy, but would any one recommend looking at an iphone alternative such as the droid?
It might be cheaper, work international, no micro-sim necessary...
I am really a noob when it comes to cell phones
For the first part.. You still need to pay some sort of monthly pre-paid option. No? Also why would you pay 700$ for a device that you can have the same stuff pretty much minus the new retina display and 5meg camera for like 200$? Biggest difference is the calling which again you said you dont use.

Also with your initial read I didnt think you even had a cell phone as you said you dont call a lot etc..

So with me assuming if you buy an iPod you wont have a cell phone, that only leaves you with a iPod and a WD media player. 2 devices.

You can buy an app textfree or whatever its called and you can text even on an iPod touch.

I dont think you really need a review between a iPhone and a iPod, because comparing the 3G/3GS to a iPod only difference is the no calling feature and no camera. And you can even text using the iPod if you get the right app. Now you can compare the iTouch to a i4 if you want but you got the basics.
 
Comment

MacBH928

macrumors 68040
Original poster
May 17, 2008
3,906
1,409
WOW
the basic difference between $200 and $700 are just calling features and a camera?

When will the new ipod touches going to be out? I hear September?
 
Comment

esadb

macrumors 65816
Nov 29, 2008
1,184
0
WOW
the basic difference between $200 and $700 are just calling features and a camera?

When will the new ipod touches going to be out? I hear September?
Yah dude, there is no difference other than the new display and the camera that the iphone can do over the iTouch.

No idea but my guess would probably say around september you would see a new iTouch..

I just know from using peoples iTouches they almost seemed to have ran better/faster than lets say my old 3G..
 
Comment

iSari

macrumors member
Jul 28, 2010
41
0
NY
Hello,
I am looking for iPhone advice, I have waited long to purchase this device but I got a couple of questions

1) How serious is the antenna issue? I got a feeling that people are way over-reacting. I didn't use one myself so I can't tell. If the issue is just to not put your finger over that tiny crack on the side of the phone, I guess I can easily do that not to mention I am buying a bumper anyways. Or is it serious?

Good question and I'm really concerned about that if I'm gonna be the new IP4

2) One of the main reason I am buying an iPhone is that I want to watch movies on my tv with it, and as far as I know, there is only one product that allows you to do this:
http://www.amazon.com/Apple-Compone...1?ie=UTF8&s=electronics&qid=1280405387&sr=8-1

The guy who recommended the WD media player is right :) +1

There are many media players out there. Do some research ;)


3) I want the iphone for its apps and media mobility, am not into talking too much, would an ipod touch be a better choice especially considering the high price difference? When will the new ipod touches going to be out?

I read that the iPod touch is almost an iPhone without the phone, so maybe its better for ya!

4)Steve Jobs mentioned that the free bumpers is just a temporary solution up until september, which is scaring me, does that mean a fixed iphone 4 is in the making after september?

I don't understand Mr. Jobs! How is this a temporary solution if some of the iPhones out there have a design problem?!! :confused:

I have a feeling that the next iPhone4's to come later this year (especially with the release of the white version) are going to be better somehow.

maybe they will "secretly" fix something in the antenna design, who knows!

when I read this I knew something was wrong
Code:
[URL="http://www.appleinsider.com/articles/10/07/15/apple_engineer_warned_steve_jobs_about_iphone_4_reception_last_year.html"]http://www.appleinsider.com/articles/10/07/15/apple_engineer_warned_steve_jobs_about_iphone_4_reception_last_year.html[/URL]

5) Can any one in the UK confirm if the iPhones from the Apple store over there are unlocked? A friend of mine bought one from the Apple store in London and came back here to asia , he popped in the cell phone chip and it worked no extra work other than cutting the the chip itself to fit in.

Yeah they are factory unlocked 100% < if you buy the phone from Apple

thanks
Good thread, Good questions! :apple:
 
Comment

Tarzanman

macrumors 65816
Jul 16, 2010
1,302
14
Hello,
I am looking for iPhone advice, I have waited long to purchase this device but I got a couple of questions
I am not an Apple fan, but I will be fair/objective.
1) How serious is the antenna issue? I got a feeling that people are way over-reacting. I didn't use one myself so I can't tell. If the issue is just to not put your finger over that tiny crack on the side of the phone, I guess I can easily do that not to mention I am buying a bumper anyways. Or is it serious?
This is a case of "Your Mileage May Vary". I would advise you to try before you buy (they give you 30 days, right?). You might be happy with the iPhone's performance as a phone, or you might have problems. A bumper should eliminate the detuning problem. After that its a matter of figuring out whether the reception and coverage of the phone is satisfactory. The only way to do that is to use it for a while in different areas.

2) One of the main reason I am buying an iPhone is that I want to watch movies on my tv with it, and as far as I know, there is only one product that allows you to do this:
http://www.amazon.com/Apple-Compone...1?ie=UTF8&s=electronics&qid=1280405387&sr=8-1
I am confused by this statement because it seems wrong? There are many products on many other phones that allow you to watch movies on your TV. Some phones even have an HDMI port, eliminating the need any proprietary connectors.

The iPhone might not be the best device for this purpose because (unless I am mistaken) the cable you linked to will prevent you from plugging the iphone in to a charger to power it while viewing a movie. It should still work, though.


3) I want the iphone for its apps and media mobility, am not into talking too much, would an ipod touch be a better choice especially considering the high price difference? When will the new ipod touches going to be out?
This is a little confusing as well. Do you need a phone or a personal media player? If you only need a personal media player/storage device then you might want to get one apart from a phone. The iPhone can do most of those things, but an iPhone will cost you ~$80 a month whereas an iPod/media player device won't.

4)Steve Jobs mentioned that the free bumpers is just a temporary solution up until september, which is scaring me, does that mean a fixed iphone 4 is in the making after september?
No one knows for sure, but most people think that the phone won't be changed until June of next year. My GUESS is that Apple might probably start bundling bumpers or cases in the box with iPhones at some point in October, hence the Sept. 30th date.

5) Can any one in the UK confirm if the iPhones from the Apple store over there are unlocked? A friend of mine bought one from the Apple store in London and came back here to asia , he popped in the cell phone chip and it worked no extra work other than cutting the the chip itself to fit in.

thanks
 
Comment

MacBH928

macrumors 68040
Original poster
May 17, 2008
3,906
1,409
Thanx for the advice everyone

Looks like WD tv is what I am looking for

$500 in price difference just to be able to use and ipod to talk is extremely high

therefor I will be buying:
WD media player
new iTouch


and who knows, I might still have money to buy an iPad

Ipad+WD media Player+iTouch= $902
just iphone4 with issues= $780
 
Comment

Similar threads

Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.