He hadn't added it yet. He needed me to meet him and unlock it (which I could obviously do since I had the info). He said Verizon was able to restore it, but that they didn't do anything special to his knowledge. How I was unable to restore it on two different machines after even disassembling it once remains a mystery.
I feel like he had more info and just wasn't saying; he was obviously happy to drop $250 on the phone. Why he didn't want to tell me is beyond me.
Yep, maybe he knew how to repair iphones and it was something small or simple to fix.
I don't buy his story that he just restored it and it just started working fine.
Either way though, you got your money so its a done deal.