I’ve read a lot of the criticism in this thread, and I get where it’s coming from. One camera. One speaker. USB-C speeds that are stuck in the past. The price, especially in comparison to other models. None of that is wrong.
But as someone who actually owns the Air, I genuinely love it, and my experience has been very different from how it’s often discussed here and in other forums.
Yes, it has one camera. I don’t shoot multiple lenses’ worth of photos every day. Yes, it has one speaker. I rarely listen to audio without AirPods and it’s fine in a room when watching a YouTube video for example. Yes, data transfer speeds could be better. I almost never move large files over a cable. These are all technically valid compromises, they just aren’t compromises I feel in my personal daily use.
What I do feel, constantly, is the physical experience of the device. The weight. The balance. The thinness. Holding your phone is something you do dozens, maybe hundreds, of times a day. For me, that matters more than specs I interact with occasionally and I’m saying all that while coming from the pro phone which I update yearly.
I scaled back this year on purpose as I wanted to hold something different and have been ranting about the pro’s weight for years. I absolutely love how focused this phone is. I haven’t felt once like I gave something up. It’s an object that feels genuinely good to use and want to hold way more than any iPhone previously.
Would I buy a next-gen Air that improves the camera, speakers, and USB-C speeds? In a heartbeat. But that doesn’t make my current experience any less satisfying.
I’m not trying to convince anyone who already knows they want the Pro features. Or the standard iPhone which is the better deal this year. That’s fine. All I’m saying that valuing how a device feels in your hand is fine too and quite frankly, the Air deserves more credit than it gets here.