Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Do you already have good, fairly-new laptop? I would prioritize that first. Preferably a mac of course. :)

A Laptop might not have the portability of a tablet or phone, but you can do more with it There's just no denying that.

If you have a laptop, or once you get one, and you have money left over, then it's time to consider an iPad or iPhone. And at that point, I would have to say the iPhone would be next priority, THEN the iPad. Yes, the iPad is bigger, but the iPhone can go with you to more places and is more portable,and does double duty as your phone.

And, while an iPad is great, you can always wait till you have more cash to get one last. Notes can be taken on the laptop if you really want to. And if not, good ol' paper is still quite useful.

and for the Ibooks text books 1 semester savings on college text books could pay for your Ipad..

http://www.apple.com/education/ibooks-textbooks/

Texbooks on the iPad are nice, definitely, and if the university is on board with e-textbooks, then it's definitely worth looking at. But, not every college is onboard yet, and I know a lot of places that are still selling books on paper and will for some time. The cost of the paper textbooks are inflated, and a lot of times it's because that money is going into the pockets of the professors teaching the courses, who also wrote or co-wrote the book. Switching to iBooks or other electronic formats just exposes where all the inflated cash is going.

This is also why students of those universities that don't police that sort of thing get screwed a lot when a professor releases (and requires you to get) the "latest edition" of the text book for that year... which often has the same material, just a page or two is changed and the content is rearranged to make it harder for people with older editions to keep up in class. It also makes the book you bought pretty much worthless, when you try to sell it back at the end of the semester. At that point it becomes a nice decoration you can put on the shelf and never read again

Not saying everyone does this, but a lot of professors do, and it's those professors who you'll see not having their books on the iPad.
 
Last edited:
If you are seriously comparing the iPhone to the iPad for note taking then the iPad wins by some margin, any kind of serious note taking on the iPhone is a horrible prospect.
 
An iPhone is.. Well an iPhone. The iPad would be better suited for what you want with its bigger screen and what not.

Yep pretty much the first response nailed it.

For me the iPhone is a must have that is with me practically 24-7, the iPad is a very useful tool which I use often and is better used as a laptop replacement but it's neither small nor a phone.
 
If you are going to record voice lectures, get something dedicated to it that will do a better job, not a phone.

http://www.amazon.com/Olympus-VN-81...?s=electronics&ie=UTF8&qid=1337873778&sr=1-23

you know you would be surprised....iPhone/iPad/iPod do an amazing job at recording....buying standalone recorders are quiet hectic to use at times when it comes to transferring files to your computer because they are getting full. I bought one for university and used it only for a few months...once I got my iPhone 3GS back in 2009 I never used my recorder again because my iPhone was so convenient and the recordings were excellent if not better than my Sony Digital voice recorder....

as for OP who started the thread I would say Go with a iPad, because iPhone isn't going to help you in school at all....other than recording lectures. You should get/have a iPad+Macbook or iPad+some sort of Desktop because I can assure you as amazing as the iPad is you just cannot live off of it for all your tasks/work/studies. You will need a desktop/laptop to fall back to at times so for that reason you should have one.

I have a Macbook Air (Recently Aquired after selling off my Macbook Pro because it was too heavy to carry along with books). Macbook Air is amazing, fits in well with my studies and the portability of moving around because it weighs (< 3 Lbs) less than most textbooks lol. You can always go with one if you wish but if you want an iPad (I still do but due to budget cannot afford one yet but sure will get one soon once second hand prices drop a bit more) then go for it but again jus remember to have a desktop/laptop at home that you can work alternatively on for things that you cannot accomplish on a iPad.
 
Last edited:
As an Amazon Associate, MacRumors earns a commission from qualifying purchases made through links in this post.
If you are really tight on money I would go for a low-end android phone (or maybe even a dumb phone), an ipod touch and a cheap dell laptop.

Best of all worlds.
 
If I had to choose, iPhone.

It does almost everything the iPad does, despite the small screen, but also makes phone calls and is easier to carry around. I'll take my iPhone to the bathroom (yeah, I know, red-flagged), use it to listen to music in my car, leave it on my desk at work, use it to play some music by the pool, etc.

Now if the iPad could make speakerphone calls...
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.