With reachability ... can you do the swipe down, and then swipe down from the middle-right of the screen to get the control center? Or do you still have to pull control center down from the very top-right of the X?
I think you're right.
I have an 8+ now, I love the screen but the phone is big, I sometimes struggle to put it into the pocket.
X is the perfect phone for 4.7'' owners, you get more vertical space for your content with the same phone's dimensions. There's the notch, but you can get used to it and even if apps aren't update to get advantage of it you still get more vertical content. Landscape mode isn't great, but most of the time you use the phone in portrait mode so it isn't a big deal.
Next year I may change my phone and while I hope they'll release a plus version of X I may decide to go for the smaller model. My only concern is the keyboard, I'm used to the larger keyboard of X and I struggle when I type on my wife's iPhone with 4.7'' so I'd have the same experience on X. But I don't like having too much bezel on my phone, so I'll be happy to get rid of that.
Unfortunately for some, I don't think Apple have any intention of releasing a larger X next year. Unless they're aware of massive demand. I think they really will push the X as being the perfect size and won't bother with a larger one. I think a lot of people round these parts convince themselves they need a bigger device, when actually they probably don't - and this is coming from a guy with larger than average hands.
Simple doesn't necessarily mean intuitive. The action of swiping down on the home screen indicator reflects the downward motion of reachability. Double tapping the home button doesn't have that same connection. Also, double tapping the home button is unknown to many people because single tapping doesn't do anything. Swiping up on the home screen indicator is already used, so swiping down is more likely to be discovered by a user on their own. Of course, the new reachability isn't enabled by default, so I guess users won't even get a chance to discover it on their own.How is it more intuitive ? You tap twice on the Touch ID phones, simple. I say it’s equal
Actually a clever and intuitive way to do it..
that seems a bit odd. Once you've done the 'swipe up and pause' to bring the task switcher up, I don't see any reason you couldn't swipe the cards away like on current devices. You're in the middle of the screen so nowhere near the 'home bar'.
How is it more intuitive ? You tap twice on the Touch ID phones, simple. I say it’s equal
Probably because Apple doesn't want you to do this at all. Far too many people still think they need to close all their apps...Apple wants to move them away from it.
[doublepost=1509469319][/doublepost]
I think you're confusing "intuitive" with "simple." It is simple to double tap Touch ID, but the double-tap action has no logical connection to Reachability. Swiping down on the indicator brings the screen down; thus it is both simple and intuitive.
Something intuitive should be simple, but something simple isn't necessarily intuitive. Much like all squares are rectangles, but not all rectangles are squares.Intuitive and simplicity go hand and hand.
I feel like you are conflating intuitive and easy.How is it more intuitive ? You tap twice on the Touch ID phones, simple. I say it’s equal
Thanks for helping explain with a very good example.Something intuitive should be simple, but something simple isn't necessarily intuitive. Much like all squares are rectangles, but not all rectangles are squares.
Imagine a feature on the phone where if you blow into the microphone, it switches wifi on/off. Simple? Yes. Intuitive? Nooooooo.