Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Guy is a joke, apple needs to wise up and blacklist him, so he can fade away into obscurity.



Does anybody remember last years iPhone X review, where he went out of his way to make Face ID look like it doesn’t work?

It seems like he has an axe to grind.
Wonder why? /s

aa031b555bf4c0cdebabfd27575fb2ec.png

edc540a2a1d4bb47ae9203b8fb8af514.png
Does he rep for Hot Topic?
 
The verge came off as incredibly bias.

Nilay looked upset that he had to review the xs max over the pixel 3.

Don’t really take his reviews at face value.

That was my impression as well. Like his good name is sullied for reviewing the iPhone Xs Max. He was sort of like that last year also.
 
  • Like
Reactions: FFR
He uses his phones without a case. It can have all the dlc coat it wants, it's going to scratch easily without a case, especially stainless steel.

Uh-huh, you never answered my question, so that’s a no on the dlc?

Yes he takes a second to admire it scratch free, before he removes the plastic film from the back of the phone.

bbf1b509db7bdf33823b5c0999f3d2e2.png


Yes he is clearly admiring the stainless steel bezel, oh wait no it’s the glass back just before he removes the plastic film.


Show me which pixel users have welcome the notch on the pixel 3. They have on the imminent one plus 6 because it's super small.
I was a pixel XL user and I hate the Pixel 3xl design if the leaks are true. Funny thing is I can be critical of things I like. You on the other hand can't.

Its “super small” on the one plus 6, Hahahaha
Ok sure.

0988fd51a02823daf170266ffc811032.jpg


Do you have a one plus 6?

As soon as the pixel 3 xl with the notch ships out I will start a thread on it in the alternatives section, just for you. ;).

I was a pixel XL user and I hate the Pixel 3xl design if the leaks are true. Funny thing is I can be critical of things I like. You on the other hand can't.

no one asked if you hated it, and i never claimed anyone would love it, doesn’t mean pixel users won’t buy it.

Are you getting a pixel 3xl?


Funny thing is I can be critical of things I like. You on the other hand can't.

Smh, some posters love to make things personal.

I wouldn’t be critical of something I liked. If I didn’t like something, such as curved displays or ufs storage, I simply wouldn’t buy it.

If Apple comes out with a curved display phone that had as much glare as my old s7 edge. I wouldn’t buy it. If Apple makes an iPhone that’s thicker than 7.9mm I wouldn’t buy it. The iPhone X’s is already approaching that limit at 7.7mm

Do you get it?

Why would anyone buy something they don’t like?
 
The Verge must be the most unbiased source because IPhone people swear they hate iPhone and in the android world their nickname is iVerge.

That’s fanboys for you. :rolleyes:

I don’t get why it’s so hard for people to just let everyone like what they like and not worry about other people’s opinions.
 
Uh-huh, you never answered my question, so that’s a no on the dlc?

Yes he takes a second to admire it scratch free, before he removes the plastic film from the back of the phone.

bbf1b509db7bdf33823b5c0999f3d2e2.png


Yes he is clearly admiring the stainless steel bezel, oh wait no it’s the glass back just before he removes the plastic film.




Its “super small” on the one plus 6, Hahahaha
Ok sure.

0988fd51a02823daf170266ffc811032.jpg


Do you have a one plus 6?

As soon as the pixel 3 xl with the notch ships out I will start a thread on it in the alternatives section, just for you. ;).



no one asked if you hated it, and i never claimed anyone would love it, doesn’t mean pixel users won’t buy it.

Are you getting a pixel 3xl?




Smh, some posters love to make things personal.

I wouldn’t be critical of something I liked. If I didn’t like something, such as curved displays or ufs storage, I simply wouldn’t buy it.

If Apple comes out with a curved display phone that had as much glare as my old s7 edge. I wouldn’t buy it. If Apple makes an iPhone that’s thicker than 7.9mm I wouldn’t buy it. The iPhone X’s is already approaching that limit at 7.7mm

Do you get it?

Why would anyone buy something they don’t like?
Lol it's a waste of time arguing with you. Just to clear up a few points because I really don't have the time to go through your entire post. I said imminent one plus 6 ( I forgot to put 6t), but that's what I meant when I said imminent. You can go and google that design and see how small the notch is.

I most certainly will not get the pixel 3xl nor why phones with a notch so big. The most I will compromise on is how it's done on the essential or one plus 6t.

Well unlike you I am critical of all things, because nothing is perfect. I know in your mind the iPhone is perfect so you don't have to tell me. Prime example, I would still love a headphone Jack, but the options are getting more and more limited. So I don't like that the upcoming one plus 6t won't have a headphone Jack but I'll have to compromise. Why? Because I'm not a fan of samsung or LG UI.

Since you are never critical of anything you like, then I am going to guess everything you have bought initially in your mind was perfect. How someone can think like that imo is beyond me. I can't think of 1 electronic I've liked or purchased that I couldn't say atleast 1 negative thing about.

Btw if you go into the alternative section with the pixel 3xl thread, you will see me as well as many other Android lovers bashing it. Check my post history.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bnekic
Are there any out that show colours other than the gold? Not a huge fan of it, and I preordered the space grey, but trying to decide if I should go for the silver instead...
 
  • Like
Reactions: EezyE
Are there any out that show colours other than the gold? Not a huge fan of it, and I preordered the space grey, but trying to decide if I should go for the silver instead...

I think you will really like the space gray, it’s more of a muted tone of black, really sharp color. Advantage with the space gray, has the PVD coating around the bands, which is a protective layer to prevent scratches, where as the silver iPhone X, has the regular stainless bands that will scratch easier.

FE3AA8A2-7BEB-45EC-AA53-97C46FB9307D.jpeg
 
The verge came off as incredibly bias.

Nilay looked upset that he had to review the xs max over the pixel 3.

Don’t really take his reviews at face value.
Seemed pretty fair to me. What part seemed baised to you?
 
Seemed pretty fair to me. What part seemed baised to you?
Any negative part. It's the usual from FFR. Once anything negative is said about iPhones they are automatically bias and getting paid off. It happens during every release.
 
  • Like
Reactions: brgjoe
I think you will really like the space gray, it’s more of a muted tone of black, really sharp color. Advantage with the space gray, has the PVD coating around the bands, which is a protective layer to prevent scratches, where as the silver iPhone X, has the regular stainless bands that will scratch easier.

View attachment 783374

My silver X I just polish to get out any minor scratches. Always looks brand spanking new when I'm done. Same with my SS watch. Feels so nice too. You can't do that with a colored band sorry to say. Once it scratches, it's done for.

However, get what works for you! Always been a fan of silver. Whenever Apple wants to bring back a true black (like they did with the matte/gloss black phones), then I will do black again. Space Gray IMO just isn't in my wheelhouse.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bnekic
Could care less of video review. Media needs to learn to write again, so much easier than watching a vid
Plenty of the reviews above have accompanying written pieces. I prefer to take in both - not so much the polished videos from the tech sites, but the more relaxed ones from individuals such as Lisa Gade (although she hasn’t published one yet).

Pretty moot in any case since there’s very little that can be said about these two devices that we don’t already know. Pretty much every review will conclude that they are the best iPhones so far but not significant enough enhancements for iPhone X owners to consider upgrading to.
 
Lol it's a waste of time arguing with you. Just to clear up a few points because I really don't have the time to go through your entire post. I said imminent one plus 6 ( I forgot to put 6t), but that's what I meant when I said imminent. You can go and google that design and see how small the notch is.

Uh-huh.
Well you replied to my post...so kind of looked like you wanted to argue.

Ofcourse you forgot the t, it happens all the time.
But it’s still a notch.

I most certainly will not get the pixel 3xl nor why phones with a notch so big. The most I will compromise on is how it's done on the essential or one plus 6t.

And that’s your prerogative , though a bit hypocritical going from no notch to a small notch just the same, but as you later stated.
Your used to comprise.

Well unlike you I am critical of all things, because nothing is perfect. I know in your mind the iPhone is perfect so you don't have to tell me. Prime example, I would still love a headphone Jack, but the options are getting more and more limited. So I don't like that the upcoming one plus 6t won't have a headphone Jack but I'll have to compromise. Why? Because I'm not a fan of samsung or LG UI.

As you should be critical since your use to compromising with android handsets so many choices never the right one.

Never said anything was perfect, that’s your words not mine, critical as you claim to be, not very thorough. Unlike android, apple’s hardware matches the ecosystem. It great, there really isn’t any competition in that regard.


Since you are never critical of anything you like, then I am going to guess everything you have bought initially in your mind was perfect. How someone can think like that imo is beyond me. I can't think of 1 electronic I've liked or purchased that I couldn't say atleast 1 negative thing about.

Yeah, that’s the thing don’t think you purchased that many electronic devices, If you have you might have a different perspective.

Personally I have. But let’s stick to mobile phones.
Here is a small sample of my personal collection, and I mean small because I have been buying nearly every high end phone I could get my hands since 1996 (except Japanese phones though I did snag a couple).

I believe this was before the release of the first iPhone.

c15e71197c11443df740837ed1b7c578.jpg


Kind of taught me a thing or two about the “perfect phone” , I will give you a hint it doesn’t exist. One of the reasons I’m not really critical, been there, done that.
Electronics, cars, property etc. Etc.

It either works or it doesn’t.
But hey I don’t really compromise.

Btw if you go into the alternative section with the pixel 3xl thread, you will see me as well as many other Android lovers bashing it. Check my post history.

Not really interested in android after my favorite phone brand went out of business.

And lately with all the crap google was pulling, I closed all my gmail accounts. Switched to duck duck go for search. And bing translate instead of googles version, this turned out great since bing translate offered an extension in the share menu, so I never have to open the app.

Didn’t do this out of paranoia or fear of wherever consumers are afraid of these days, I did it because they repeatedly lied about it.
Once trust is gone, I take my business elsewhere.

But I am interested in hardware, always have and will.

Enjoy whatever compromise you land on.
You know best.
 
Does he rep for Hot Topic?

Rep?
Think he is their mascot .

That was my impression as well. Like his good name is sullied for reviewing the iPhone Xs Max. He was sort of like that last year also.

Yeah.

I was watching it and thinking, Did he really start the review with:
“Im never going to forgive Apple for naming the iPhone X’s max.”

I couldn’t stop laughing.

He really didn’t want to do it, I think he was forced to.

Last year, was a bit pathetic really, he went out of his way to prove that Face ID was fail, but I couldn’t stop laughing at him trying to unlock face is from his waist.

Who does that?
 
Last edited:
First review I've seen showing the Xs Max side by side with Galaxy Note 9 in a video...at 2:30

 
  • Like
Reactions: brgjoe
We need these reviewers to start talking about the data speeds and the 2X faster speeds on the XS vs the X .
 
MKBHD recently uploaded his iPhone Xs video review, and I’ve gotta say, I feel he rushed it. Certainly not his normal quality. Only had a few Xs camera sample shots, had slightly wrong info on water resistance, and no mention of some Xs improvements like better cellular connectivity, extended dynamic range for 30fps video, and 1080p 60 on front camera.

Take away from his review is that the Max is probably the one to get, and that the camera is the main reason to upgrade (after larger screen size of the Max) being close to Pixel 2 quality in terms of photo’s, and exceeding the competition on video recording capabilities.
 
Last edited:
He's an android guy. He's not really a fan of any iphone.
He carries an iPhone at all times as well, and has specifically said in multiple videos that iOS just does some things better for what he needs.
 
Are there any out that show colours other than the gold? Not a huge fan of it, and I preordered the space grey, but trying to decide if I should go for the silver instead...

I’d love to see a review of a space grey model as that’s what I ordered as well. My 5 was space grey, my 6 was silver, and my 7 was space grey. Since my X is silver, I went with space grey for the Max. The silver is pretty but, I wanted to go back to space grey again. On the silver X, the band was natural stainless and the back was closer to white.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.