Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
applekid said:
Even though I'm a proud owner of the 3G iPod, I have doubts about us ever seeing any updates to get us the features the 4G iPod has. There's so many internal changes in the 4G iPod, I don't think it's even a possibility to get the same features.

Your right.. I'd be really surprised if you'll ever get G4 functionality in the G3 iPods. Apple didn't give G1/G2 iPod owners the G3 functionality.

There would be even less incentive for G2/G3 owners to buy a G4 iPod.
 
This is garbage on Apple's part. Weeks ago people were telling me that it MUST be impossible for Apple to bring the 3.0 software features to the 3Gen. iPods. This same group of people also said that it would be stupid to bring such features to older model iPods. But now they are saying this is a brilliant marketing plan for Apple, now that they are supporting an older iPod model. I thought being an Yes-Man was a characteristic only exclusive to the Windows world.
 
hehe

i hope apple doesnt break real.

and not for the immedieately seen reason.

real is bad.

very bad.

and apperently rhapsody isnt all that well implemented.

and it doesnt EFFECTIVELY work with ipod.

so...let people use it. and simply emphasize the first party goodness that it is a well designed stystem.

it would also be one big "i don't give a left loogie" to real.
 
I misunderstood the last iPod update, thinking it put Shuffle on the main menu for minis too. Now at last it looks like I'll get what I thought I was already getting.

I'm going to guess that they won't have new code to detect Real tunes in the iPod Mini update, because I think they would issue updates for all iPods if and when they do that.
 
Stella said:
Your right.. I'd be really surprised if you'll ever get G4 functionality in the G3 iPods. Apple didn't give G1/G2 iPod owners the G3 functionality.

There would be even less incentive for G2/G3 owners to buy a G4 iPod.

it's a tactical choice that Real's intrusion inspired.
Apple, I'm sure, didn't havve this update in there plans until Real broke the door down.

I think it's smart and good for mini users
 
morkintosh said:
no you want them to wait a while until a bunch of people buy songs at 0.49 each, then after consumers have spent a bunch of money do a critical update rendering the real songs worthless or some iPod users without outdated firmware. Either Real gets left holding the bag.

Forgive me if this has already been asked, but wouldn't it be the consumers who purchased from Real the ones geting screwed?
 
joeboy_45101 said:
This is garbage on Apple's part. Weeks ago people were telling me that it MUST be impossible for Apple to bring the 3.0 software features to the 3Gen. iPods. This same group of people also said that it would be stupid to bring such features to older model iPods..

The iPod mini is kind of a Gen 3.5 iPod when you think about it. It came out with a bunch of little hardware upgrades (like the clickwheel and a newer processor). It also sports a few of the features that the 3G doesn't have, like headphone recognition and USB 2.0 charging. So you see it is possible to bring the 3.0 software to minis (in the form of 1.2), but the mini's been around less than 8 months while the 3G iPod's been around a lot longer than that man--give em a brake.
 
musicpyrite said:
This is probably just an excuse to stop Real.

And I hope they provide an update to 1st, 2nd, and 3rd generation iPods, but I doubt it. 🙁

Rhapsody, judo chop!
 
iPod Mini

It may just be me but I've never really thought of my mini as a small 3G iPod, but rather the first 4G iPod, using the click wheel as the dicerning factor.

After all, didn't it's big brother just catch up?

So it seems only natural that the iPod Mini has the latest features available.

But maybe it's just me. 😕

~iGuy
 
Cool! Nice to hear the minis get the 4G features too, it's just a smaller 4G after all.
This doesn't affect me though, I bought a 4G one last month, just waiting it to ship, should be today...I never was in the iPod mini market anyway. They're in many ways superior (durable alu casing, weight, size) to the normal iPods, but I can't fit 6.7 gigs of music, plus my home directory on that. And I just couldn't wait 3 months for the mini arriving to Finland.
Speaking of waiting, I got an e-mail from Apple telling that "due to huge demand for this product" my shipping date was being moved from 18th to 20th August, not a big change, but still. And I haven't yet got an Shipping confirmation e-mail. Can't wait...! What's weird is, that it's not only the iPod (wait 6-8 days), but the new 4G dock and 4G 20 GB case (wait 1-2 weeks). Also, the In-Ear headphones had a longwaiting time, 6-8 days. I have been already waiting nearly 3 weeks though, my order was dated 29th July. Lucky I'm not on the PowerMac delays though...
 
morkintosh said:
no you want them to wait a while until a bunch of people buy songs at 0.49 each, then after consumers have spent a bunch of money do a critical update rendering the real songs worthless or some iPod users without outdated firmware. Either Real gets left holding the bag.

The earlier apple "fixes" their problem with Real the better for apple. The more people that have songs from REAL on their iPod the more people are going to cry and whine and cause apple problems.
 
Lancetx said:
This update won't block Rhapsody because in order to do that, Apple will have to change their copy protection scheme up some (again). If they were to do that, they would have to update all iPods or else they would no longer play music from the iTMS.

You'd think that Apple could update the firmware easy enough to just not play any 192K encoded songs with DRM as they must have come from Real. Any 128k encoded songs with DRM would be from iTMS and would still play fine. Also any 192k songs that people encoded themselves would not have any DRM and would still play just fine.
 
bankshot said:
I won't be buying a new iPoduntil they finally solve the gap problem. It can't be difficult.

I'd REALLY like crossfade. So many songs end choppily when taken out of order. iTunes' crossfade for 2 seconds makes my music less intrusive and choppy between songs.

I'd also like iTunes custom equalizers to show up on iPod. So you can custom-adjust for different headphones, noise conditions, etc. (I don't even care whether you can set EQ levels on the iPod itself.)
 
Apple did warn people -
DO NOT BUY AAC FILES FROM REAL.. THEY MAY NOT WORK IN THE FUTURE.

So really, Apple aren't screwing them - they have been warned, and they can still play these files in Realplayer - just not on iPod.

Porchland said:
Yes. Next question.

Originally Posted by MacKenzie999

Forgive me if this has already been asked, but wouldn't it be the consumers who purchased from Real the ones geting screwed?



Yes. Next question.
 
The whole REAL thing is overstated

it's not widely realized that REAL has very few customers compared to ITMS. I don't see how this can be bad for Apple. Yes, it's bad that the copy protection was cracked, but the only thing that Harmony will really do is allow it's users to use the iPod. This will only sell more iPods for Apple. As long as other groups don't start cracking the iPod, this developement isn't that bad at all for Apple. What's happening to Apple here is the equivalent of them licensing other computer makers to make macs, but the difference is that Apple isn't allowing it. When IBM licensed the PC to other companies, it was good for their business. then they screwed up and had to basically withdraw from it, but hopefully Apple won't have to do that.
 
I agree with you

nagromme said:
I'd REALLY like crossfade. So many songs end choppily when taken out of order. iTunes' crossfade for 2 seconds makes my music less intrusive and choppy between songs.

I'd also like iTunes custom equalizers to show up on iPod. So you can custom-adjust for different headphones, noise conditions, etc. (I don't even care whether you can set EQ levels on the iPod itself.)

I love the crossfade feature on itunes, I wish Apple would put it in the ipods... 😎
 
Hi guys. Question. How does Apple notify, if at all, users of new firmware on their iPods? Is it an iTunes feature? Sort of like a notification prompt? I ask because releasing a "fix" for harmony is all well and good but how many users would know about the new firmware to install it? If Apple is looking at breaking harmony across the board they need to have it installed on as many iPods as possible otherwise they are going to simply confuse users:

Joe: "Dude, have you tried Real's music for .50 cents?"
Bob: "Nope it doesn't work on my iPod"
Joe: "But it works on mine and Franks, you must have a busted iPod."

Something along those lines. 😕
 
joeboy_45101 said:
This is garbage on Apple's part. Weeks ago people were telling me that it MUST be impossible for Apple to bring the 3.0 software features to the 3Gen. iPods. This same group of people also said that it would be stupid to bring such features to older model iPods. But now they are saying this is a brilliant marketing plan for Apple, now that they are supporting an older iPod model. I thought being an Yes-Man was a characteristic only exclusive to the Windows world.
There's nothing "yes-man" about it.
It makes sense for Apple to update the software on the mini, because they didn't release a new iPod mini.
The mini and the regular iPod are not related the same way the 3G and the 4G iPods are. They're two different product lines. Coexisiting at the same time.

On the hardware side of things, you should realize that the mini's are more like the 4G than the 3G on the inside. Much of the technology and design packed into the 4G iPod has been adapted from that of the mini. The 3G iPod was eight months old when the mini was introduced, while the mini was only six months old when the 4G iPod was released.

You might not like the fact that Apple won't update the 3G iPod's software, but there's no reason for Apple to do it. From a business standpoint (remember, Apple is a company), the best thing for Apple to do is let the older models get outdated so people have a reason to upgrade.

The only thing this update for the mini means is that Apple won't release new mini's any time soon.
 
I have it in My Hard Drive

Its in Software Update. But my wife has the iPod with her so I can't update my 3G if there are any from the last update. 🙁
 
bankshot said:
No, the difference is they put it in the main menu on the 4th gen iPods. I suggested it to them, but that was for the 3rd gen that I have! 😱

So let me be the first to say... WAAAA!!! I want the new features on my 3rd gen iPod!! 🙄 😀

But seriously, I won't be buying a new iPoduntil they finally solve the gap problem. It can't be difficult. When importing CDs, iTunes could store the exact cutoff time of the end of the track, down to the sample level. Then during playback, just play up to that time before switching to the next song so you don't get the remaining silence in the last frame. If you buffer your audio output, you can start reading the next song and filling the buffer before the current one finishes, to guarantee there'll be no delay in changing songs.

I mean come on, CD players have done this for 20 years. How hard is it? WAAAAAA!!! Hehe. 😛

I dont have an ipod (yet - c'mon 60gb!), but I recently set up airport express and this gap issue is driving me nuts. never heard anyone mention in before anywhere - glad it's not just me. itunes can obviously buffer enough to deal with this - you can set a 12 second cross fade. it really surprises me that these gaps exist - as you said, if cds fixed the problem 20 years ago...

sorry for off-topic....
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.