My girlfriend has hinted at wanting a new iPod for Christmas, and it is something I am taking into consideration. Her current model is an old 20GB iPod Classic 4G, which is on the fritz with hard drive errors. Since I am considering getting her a new one, I wanted to ask for some advice. I had wanted to get her something close to the size of her 20GB, and the iPod Nano offers the 16GB model, which is close to that amount of space with a reasonable price tag. I keep reading many negative reviews on the new iPod Nano 6G, which makes me hesitate to move forward. I tried one at our local Apple Store, and I have to agree that it feels a bit clunky (my iPhone is my frame of reference for Multi-Touch). There is also the iPod Touch, with an 8GB model for $40-$50 more and an obvious improvement in functionality over the Nano. The problem is that it is less than half the space of her old iPod Classic. She also already has a Droid phone, which carries similar features to the iPod Touch and the iPhone that she does use. I would be afraid that an iPod Touch (as cool as she says the iPod Touches are), might be redundant. She does not play games too much either. I don't want to sound cheap--I would consider the 32GB model for $300, which would resolve the storage space issue, but I think my girlfriend would kill me if she knew I broke the bank on her. Given what I just said, I was wondering if I might seek an opinion. For her should I consider iPod Nano 6G 16GB? Or should I consider iPod Touch 4G 8GB? Thank you!