I am on my second. First had bottom 25% of screen in portrait mode was dead, totally non-responsive.
Got a second and all is fine except that on the long bottom side of the player the chrome does not match up to the bezel correctly, the chrome sticks out ever so slightly. I am in 2 minds as to whether to get it swapped as otherwise it functions fine. A bit like getting a new car and finding a dent in the wing I guess, annoying but doesn't affect the running of the car.
Any views on whether I should get them to swap it. I have ordered an Xtrememac Microshield case and my only thought is whether I will have a problem getting it to fit as it is not exactly the shape it should be!
Crazy that you all have needed so many replacements. I'm on my first one and still going strong five weeks later. Of course, my previous iPod (a first gen, fall of '01 ROCK ON!) needed to be replaced twice in the first two months. After that, though, it was as trusty as anything for the next six years. I kid you not, the thing completely died on me THE DAY I got my Touch for my birthday. It had served me with every ounce of energy. I almost thought I should bury it in the backyard. But back on topic, my Touch has been problem free.
I'm doing the exact same thing. I might give it a go again in February or March, but for now im loving my iPod classicWent through 3 replacements before returning for a full refund. I'm waiting for quality-control issues to be resolved before attempting again.