Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

AHDuke99

macrumors 68020
Original poster
Nov 14, 2002
2,325
163
Charleston, SC
I swear, I've tried everything. I erased everything in mail and resetup gmail imap and mail crashes when it connects to it before loading any messages. my other email from school works fine, but gmail hasnt worked since it worked flawlessly in the first two weeks. has anyone used gmail imap for a while? i guess i'll switch to thunderbird.

well i get a timeout for imap.gmail.com on thunderbird .. so i'll try entourage... maybe imap gmail no longer works.

seems to be loading fine in entourage.....i guess thats my mail client now :(
 
like everyone else gmail (IMAP) works just fine with mail.app
 
I swear, I've tried everything. I erased everything in mail and resetup gmail imap and mail crashes when it connects to it before loading any messages. my other email from school works fine, but gmail hasnt worked since it worked flawlessly in the first two weeks. has anyone used gmail imap for a while? i guess i'll switch to thunderbird.

I have set up imap gmail on multiple macs using mail and all work perfectly. I may be stating the obvious, but when setting it up you need to uncheck autoconfigure, change dropdown to imap, change pop.#### to imap.### for the server address and then just click click click.
 
I have been using gmail imap with apple mail with no issues whatsoever...

If you are happy with entourage you should stick to it but apple mail sure is worth another try in my opinion.
here is a link that I think might be helpful (maybe)
http://5thirtyone.com/archives/862#comment-52861

good luck

i'm not happy with entourage .. but i cannot get mail or thunderbird to work with it without crashing the apps.
 
I am so happy Gmail introduced IMAP. Mail's handling of IMAP wasn't the best, but I find it much better in Leopard.

I did have one problem this week though that the SMTP server just wouldn't work. This hasn't got to do with IMAP though and I think it's a Mail.app problem. I had to delete my Gmail account in preferences and re-do the thing from scratch.. then it worked. So strange.
 
I swear, I've tried everything. I erased everything in mail and resetup gmail imap and mail crashes when it connects to it before loading any messages. my other email from school works fine, but gmail hasnt worked since it worked flawlessly in the first two weeks. has anyone used gmail imap for a while? i guess i'll switch to thunderbird.

i use imap gmail with mail, works fine, but now, i have more messages in my inbox in mail then i do online!!!! i accidentally deleted my all mail folder in mail, put it back, now everything is messed up!!!!!

here is the link: http://mail.google.com/support/bin/answer.py?answer=81379

click on it, it gives the directions, but do what is below first!!!!

dont forget that when you want to download mail in an email client, first, you need to sign onto gmail online, click on settings, and then you should see a tab about imap, pop, or accounts, forwarding email, just look for the tab that allows you to enable IMAP, the email wont download unless you enable it from the settings online!!!!!!, maybe thats your problem
 
I use GMail (and Google Apps) accounts with Mail 3.0 on two machines, and it works pretty well except it doesn't consistently mark messages as read. Sometimes after reading all my day's messages at work on my MacBook Pro, I'll come home and they'll still be listed as unread in Mail on my iMac.
 
Count me in as someone who has had no problems. Both my wife and I use IMAP on Mail and it has worked flawlessly.
 
i'm not happy with entourage .. but i cannot get mail or thunderbird to work with it without crashing the apps.

maybe the problem isn't so much gmail but rather some corrupted files or messed up permissions?
have you tried repairing permissions yet?
 
With Gmail IMAP and Mail.app, do you still get unread messages in "All Mail" after they've been read in your inbox? And if you delete a message in Mail.app, is it simply given the label "Deleted" on Gmail's servers instead of actually being moved to the trash?
 
With Gmail IMAP and Mail.app, do you still get unread messages in "All Mail" after they've been read in your inbox? And if you delete a message in Mail.app, is it simply given the label "Deleted" on Gmail's servers instead of actually being moved to the trash?

for the first question, yes, second, no, it will be moved to the trash
 
i have using it on both mail 2 and 3. The only problem i have had is that somethings (randomly) messages that i have typed in mail show up as multiply messages in a conversation...ie the first 100 words will be in on message and then the nest 50 will be in another message...all under one conversation...really weird
 
can someone explain to be the benefit of switching to imap. I have 2 gmail accounts that I use w/ mail, and one account gets mail forwarded from another email address.
 
can someone explain to be the benefit of switching to imap. I have 2 gmail accounts that I use w/ mail, and one account gets mail forwarded from another email address.

POP is where the client (mail.app) downloads the emails, and it is all managed on your computer,

IMAP is where the client manages all the email on the server. So when you move an email to a folder in mail.app it will move it to a folder on the gmail server. This means you will also be able to setup your email accounts on multiple computers and everything will stay in sync...
 
i had a million problems with gmail imap to work on mail.app before i upgraded to leopard. i've switched to thunderbird since. however right now i'll begin using mail 3.0 and imap gmail to see if it works, i'll let you know if i have problems.


r.
 
Gmail IMAP in Mail works well for me too. The only issue is that every mail also appears in the All Mail Folder, so every mail received shows up twice. If I delete one in the Inbox, I also have to delete it again in the All Mail Folder. I have posted this on the Gmail Help, but no response so far. Any ideas?
 
Gmail IMAP in Mail works well for me too. The only issue is that every mail also appears in the All Mail Folder, so every mail received shows up twice. If I delete one in the Inbox, I also have to delete it again in the All Mail Folder. I have posted this on the Gmail Help, but no response so far. Any ideas?

I am interested in this also...because the way it is now you basically have every mail as a duplicate which is really a waste of space...
 
Advanced IMAP Controls

Advanced IMAP Controls are now available via the Labs tab in Gmail Settings.

summary from Google Groups for Gmail

Our engineers have been working to enhance the Gmail IMAP experience
since we launched IMAP access last year. Now, with a new Labs feature
written by Jamie Nicolson, you can have more control over how IMAP
works with your account.

Here's what this feature can do:

- Choose which labels to sync in IMAP (Folder subscriptions)

This can be very handy if, for example, you find your mail client
choking on a big [Gmail]/All Mail folder. Just sign into Gmail and
click 'Settings,' then click the 'Labels' tab. You'll see a new
checkbox next to each of your labels called 'Show in IMAP.' If you
uncheck that box, the corresponding folder will disappear from IMAP.

- Turn off auto-expunge

If you don't know what this means, then you probably don't want to
change it. :) The IMAP protocol allows messages to be marked for
deletion, a sort of limbo state where a message is still present in
the folder but is slated to be deleted the next time the folder is
expunged or compacted. When we launched Gmail IMAP, we thought it
would confuse people to have messages in this state, since there's
nothing like it in the web interface (the Trash label works
differently). So in our IMAP implementation, when you mark a message
as deleted, Gmail doesn't let it linger in that state -- it goes ahead
and deletes it from the folder completely. We call this auto-expunge.
This may have saved some people from confusion, but other users still
wanted the two-stage delete process. Now with this setting, all users
have a choice. To turn off auto-expunge, just sign into Gmail and
click 'Settings,' then click the 'Forwarding and POP/IMAP' tab. In the
'IMAP Access:' section, select 'Do not automatically expunge
messages.'

- Trash messages when they're no longer visible through IMAP

This advanced setting also helps users replicate a non-Gmail IMAP
experience. Most IMAP systems don't share Gmail's concept of archiving
messages. Some IMAP users find this annoying; when they delete a
message, they want it really to be gone, not "hiding" in All Mail. Of
course, they could drag the message to the [Gmail]/Trash folder, but
this is more cumbersome than just deleting the message. With this
setting, whenever a message is deleted from an IMAP folder, our system
checks to see if the message is also present in any other visible IMAP
folders (those folders which haven't been hidden from IMAP). If the
message is not present in any other visible folders -- that is, the
message is about to become inaccessible through IMAP -- then Gmail
will move the message to Trash. To enable this behavior, just sign
into Gmail and click 'Settings,' then click the 'Forwarding and POP/
IMAP' tab. In the 'IMAP Access:' section, find the 'When a message is
deleted from the last visible IMAP folder:' option. Select 'Move the
message to the Gmail Trash.' If you want to take it one step further,
you can select 'Immediately delete the message forever.' That's living
dangerously!

To check out these settings, enable the Advanced IMAP Controls feature
first by signing into Gmail and then clicking 'Settings' and then
'Labs.'
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.