Is HD Retina overrated?

No, it isn't overrated, in my opinion. Read the display analysis at DisplayMate. iPhone 6 battery life would have died with a 1080p screen.

 

Crisper fonts? BS. Fonts on the 6 Plus are ridiculously sharp UNLESS you are using an app that has not been updated yet for the screen, or is using some kind of crappy proprietary antialiasing. From The Verge review:

Deeper blacks, yes, OLED has it beat there (but this is usually only noticeable in a dark environment).

 

I tend to agree and this was one of the reasons I went for the 6+. I feel there is little real functional difference between the 6+ and my LG G3, but the display on the smaller 6 is quite inferior.

 

This whole Retina marketing spin makes me dizzy. I wanted an HD iPhone. Thank you Apple for making the 6 Plus.

 

I don't think it's overrated. When using my iPad mini 1st gen at the same time as my 6+, I can tell a big difference..

 

Crisper, yes, the S5 has 1080p... over twice the pixels, almost a third more pixel density. 6 Plus is very sharp, I could hardly see the pixels! iPhone 6 screen I am impressed with, even though it has lower ppi. It just looks really good. Neither can match the Note 4 though

 

So you can make out individual pixels on the iPhone 6 + screen?

 

You realise both the S5 and 6+ have a 1080P display right?

 

OK, I still have the Galaxy S5 and got the new iPhone 6. Will put S5 on eBay sometime this week. But here is what I have noticed comparing them side by side, both on full brightens.

Colours on the S5 seem a bit more vivid, or saturated. Under sunlight the S5 screen is lot less visible then the iPhone 6 and that did surprise me because I wasn't expecting that. I don't know if that's the improved contrast or what it is.
If I get the chance (and some sun around here) I will take a comparison photo to show what I mean.

As for the crisper fonts on the iP6+ I have tried myself and I think it is a mind playing tricks because it is a larger screen!

 

Guys. He's talking about the iPhone 6 not being as sharp. Not the 6 plus.

And the Galaxy s5 will be sharper for fonts but for most other things it'll be the same if not less sharp than the regular 6.

The Galaxy s5 uses a pentile display and that makes things a lot less sharp as not ever pixel has all three RGB colors.

 

Hardly? Meaning you can actually manage to see any? You must have some perfect vision!