It wasn't about just holding down the volume button. You have to unlock the phone before you can use the volume buttons to control muting
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Is IP7 losing the mute button?!
- Thread starter spinedoc77
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
As it is right now, yes, however what I was referencing is what someone suggested might be a way doing it while the phone is locked if the mute switch was removed.
You bring up a good point. And seeing how the sim tray has a rubber gasket why bother waterproofing a switch when all you have to do is remove it.
It's not about being lazy, it's about having better things to do than second guess which arcane combo of volume/home/whatever buttons is going to silence the phone. The volume switches already mean different things in different contexts (volume of music, volume of alerts, declining an incoming call...), and the home button does about a million things as well, from unlocking the phone to initiating Apple Pay to Siri, to... you get the point. And neither of these can tell you its state in a tactile manner in the dark or in your pocket. Think about it: many of the times when you need to silence your phone are the exact times when you maybe don't want to take it out and fiddle with it.
The switch does this perfectly. It does ONE thing, does it consistently, and it's self-evident which state it's in.
Ahh, ok, I didn't realize. There's this thing you can do called "not using your phone", and it's pretty great.
Last edited:
This is easy to implement with volume buttons.
Hold down volume down for two seconds to mute. The phone would buzz twice quickly to confirm.
Hold down volume up for two seconds to unmute. The phone would chirp to confirm.
I still prefer the physical switch, but its absence doesn't HAVE to be horrible if it's well-implemented.
Hold down volume down for two seconds to mute. The phone would buzz twice quickly to confirm.
Hold down volume up for two seconds to unmute. The phone would chirp to confirm.
I still prefer the physical switch, but its absence doesn't HAVE to be horrible if it's well-implemented.
You are reinforcing the point of getting ride of a single switch. A switch that does, one, thing, only. An...arcane switch.
My iPad Pro and S7 Edge do pretty well without a rocker switch when I need to mute it.
If you really leave your phone in your pocket so often and it's so inconvenient to take it out and 'fiddle with' when you need to mute it, why not just leave it in silent/vibrate mode?
You get the point.
That could be because the switch is used a lot less frequently on iPads than iPhones. Personally, I can probably count on two hands (maybe one) the number of times I've used that switch on my iPad. My phone is a different story. And I almost think I'd get even more use out of that switch as a rotation lock/unlock...
Good to hear it's not going away. For the morons who say it's laziness, sorry but sometimes I have better things to do or maybe I only have one hand available. I've always had issues with other phones with accidental presses changing the volume, but with the physical mute switch it's very difficult to accidentally press it.
Good for you. Not the case for everyone.
Great idea. You solved everyone's problem! Hey everybody, just leave your phones on silent all the time becuase this guy doesn't like there being a mute switch.