I agree with the other posters... it really is up to you. It's your money.
That said, if you want this phone because you will regularly use the Internet on your phone, and you would like to have a phone and and iPod in one unit, then it is worth considering.
Forget the cost up front. I mean, you only have to pay that once.
The monthly charge is the big concern. If you don't think you're going to use the Internet that often from your mobile phone, then why pay 30 bucks (or 20, if you can find a first gen iPhone) every. single. month.?
YannowhatImean?
If you are buying one just because everyone else has one, you'll probably regret the purchase. You don't NEED an iPhone. You have to want one, and appreciate the functionality and styling of the phone.
I bought the 1st gen on launch day. I didn't stand in line (I do have some dignity... um... no offense to all of you who DID stand in line, we all have our limits, yanno). I paid full price. Apple lowered the price by 200 bucks shortly afterward. I was annoyed. I got my 100-dollar store credit, and, I guess in a sort of up yours Steve maneuver, I bought something that was NOT Apple branded.
I swore I wouldn't upgrade to 3g, because the data plan for the 1st gen was 10 bucks cheaper per month (15 cheaper if you add in the free text messages you get).
Then, I found out... I could get back my corporate discount with a 3g phone! (cue Hallelujah chorus)
Soo... I just upgraded mine last weekend.
But... I still have the same old iBook G4 that I bought back in August of 2005. I'm no Apple FanGirl.
I just like my iPhone.
So there. If you think you'll really, truly, like this phone, and you'll use the data plan to make it worth the money... buy it.
But it is quirky, and you have to baby it now and then. And it will crash occasionally, but dude?
ALL cell phones do that. I know. I used to sell them part-time when I first started grad school.
