Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Is the smart cover enough?
- Thread starter act1980
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
Not really answerable in a definitive manner.
Some people use an ipad with no protection at all for months; and it still looks brand new.
Others can't go 12 hours with a dent or scratch!
Which one of these groups do you fit in? Do you throw your ipad in a bookbag with a bunch of other cr*p, or does it go in an organized briefcase in it's own pocket, or does it sit on the sofa at home and never leave the house? Do you just set it down on any surface be it wood or tile or rough concrete, or do you always pay attention and set it down on something soft or protective?
I tend to only need a little bit of protection on my stuff, so I'm using a smart cover with a BestSkinsEver skin on the back.
Some people use an ipad with no protection at all for months; and it still looks brand new.
Others can't go 12 hours with a dent or scratch!
Which one of these groups do you fit in? Do you throw your ipad in a bookbag with a bunch of other cr*p, or does it go in an organized briefcase in it's own pocket, or does it sit on the sofa at home and never leave the house? Do you just set it down on any surface be it wood or tile or rough concrete, or do you always pay attention and set it down on something soft or protective?
I tend to only need a little bit of protection on my stuff, so I'm using a smart cover with a BestSkinsEver skin on the back.
iSingandiDance
macrumors 6502a
Keep in mind, unlike your MBP which has little rubber feet on the bottom preventing the aluminum bottom from contacting the supporting surface, the iPad's aluminum rests directly on the table/desk/whetever.
Something as common as pushing your iPad a few inches across a hard surface with one or two grains of sand may yield a scratch.
Something as common as pushing your iPad a few inches across a hard surface with one or two grains of sand may yield a scratch.
I used to have cases protecting my various iPod touches, original iPod, and iPod nano. Now, I am wondering why go to such lengths of protection? Okay, so I get the idea is to protect the metal/plastic skin of the various iDevices from scratches and blemishes but the irony here is that the cases or skin protectors are NEVER removed so we basically end up covering up the beauty of the iDevices never going to enjoy its aesthetics and rather end up looking at blemished skin. That makes no sense at all! We end up not just thinking we're protecting the metal skin of the iDevice but actually just covering up the skin for perpetuity.
So for the new iPad 2 that I'll be getting, I'm only planning on getting the Smart Cover but no case, no screen protector, and no skin. I can't see a point in getting a case to protect a device whose skin we'll never be seeing any way if we end up using a protective covering.
I do keep a cover on my iPhone simply because it's impossible not to at least occasionally have to keep it in some relatively punishing environments (pants pockets, backpacks, etc), plus it's at a much higher risk of being dropped.
But for the iPad? Nah. I did usually keep my iPad 1 in the Apple case, but it was always the screen I was worried about protecting, not the back. No matter what you do, the back is inevitably going to get a scuff here and there, so there's no sense worrying too much.
It's kinda like a new car. You're completely neurotic about keeping it clean and worrying about parking lot dings, until the first time you spill a bit of Dr. Pepper on the passenger seat. Then you start to put it all in perspective and chill out about it.
But for the iPad? Nah. I did usually keep my iPad 1 in the Apple case, but it was always the screen I was worried about protecting, not the back. No matter what you do, the back is inevitably going to get a scuff here and there, so there's no sense worrying too much.
It's kinda like a new car. You're completely neurotic about keeping it clean and worrying about parking lot dings, until the first time you spill a bit of Dr. Pepper on the passenger seat. Then you start to put it all in perspective and chill out about it.
The smart cover is not enough to prevent scratches to the back. It will eventually get scratched. If youre worried about this I suggest getting a wrapsol skin, I recently put on the back skin and it fits perfectly,feels great and protects the back adequetly from scratches while still allowing for use of the smart cover.
This is so true. I remember trying to keep my car clean for the longest time till I spilled a coffee on the seat and it went downhill from there, now I don't even know what creatures on under my seats. lol
miamialley
macrumors 68040
Smart cover for screen, Best Skins Ever skin for the back, sleeve to carry it in when traveling. Works great. I for one need a skin on the back so I don't have to worry about setting it down on a table or wherever where it might get scratched. Not that that would ruin it, but I like keeping my devices as pristine as possible because I always end up selling them when the newer model comes out. Bring on the iPad 3!
I just use it and a neoprene sleeve when putting it in a bag etc.
I also don't have kids and I'm not anal about minor scratches as I'm not one who'll be selling and upgrading every year.
I also don't have kids and I'm not anal about minor scratches as I'm not one who'll be selling and upgrading every year.
v66jack
macrumors 6502a
I used my iPad 1 all year naked. No scratches on the back what-so-ever. Im a student it's been in bags, cars, trains thrown around all over the place. Not a scratch. The screen has a couple of deep scratches though.
So I'd say use the smart cover and that will be fine. My back is still looking beautiful.
So I'd say use the smart cover and that will be fine. My back is still looking beautiful.
Nothing is scratch proof. But it is very resistant to scratches just like the iPhone.
I also often set my ipad on top of my neoprene sleeve if I'm using it public etc. as another way to avoid scratches.
Last edited:
iSingandiDance
macrumors 6502a
Or flipping the cover to the back.
The iPad deserves to be naked. The aluminum backing isn't that susceptible to scratching with regular use. Now, if you're blending it, that's a whole different story.
I have a Smart Cover and I just felt it needed something on the back. I got an iCarbons black skin. Adds a little "texture" to the feel. At some point once the "newness" wears off, I'll probably go nekked - I usually do on all of my devices.
steadysignal
macrumors 6502a
This are absolutely the best. Been using them on the iphone for years.
You will need a few of them - since the scratches go on the cover itself. cheap and effective.
and retains the thinness...
