Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Alexh614

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Jul 25, 2008
18
0
My silent switch on my iPhone 3G requires A LOT of force to go back and forth and it feels like it's broken/jammed. Are all phone switches supposed to require this much force? When I tried my friends switch it went back and forth with ease and I thought maybe his was broken and mine was right, but now I'm thinking it's the opposite. Can I get this replaced and if so can ATT do it? The nearest Apple Store is 2 and a half hours away.
 
My silent switch on my iPhone 3G requires A LOT of force to go back and forth and it feels like it's broken/jammed. Are all phone switches supposed to require this much force? When I tried my friends switch it went back and forth with ease and I thought maybe his was broken and mine was right, but now I'm thinking it's the opposite. Can I get this replaced and if so can ATT do it? The nearest Apple Store is 2 and a half hours away.

in my iPhone 1.0(GOT LOOKING AT THOSE UNBOXING PICS OF 3G I WANT THAT SOOO BAD NOW!!) but i dont think HIS is broken, mine slides very easily, at first i didnt know it even had one, i thought it was a sensor for wi-fi or something like along those lines..
 
Can you flip it on and off? If so, I say keep yours.

My iPhone 3g requires more force to switch than my original iPhone which is good because my original iPhone could switch to silent in my pocket.
 
Can you flip it on and off? If so, I say keep yours.

My iPhone 3g requires more force to switch than my original iPhone which is good because my original iPhone could switch to silent in my pocket.
Sometimes, and then other times it gets stuck. If it's broken I don't want to keep it, the silent switch being so hard to control is really annoying.
 
Sometimes, and then other times it gets stuck. If it's broken I don't want to keep it, the silent switch being so hard to control is really annoying.

Mine had the same issue and it broke off on day 1. I still kept it though. Yours is defective, its your choice if you want to keep it.
 
Did you get some dirt in there?
No, it's been like that since I got it. I'm afraid if I take it to Apple they will think I got something in the switch and just want a new one to replace it because of something that's my fault. It's just that I thought it was normal because during the first couple of weeks I had no other iPhone switches to compare it to.
 
The 3G I bought on launch day had this issue. I took it back on Saturday (the next day) and it was swapped out for a brand new phone, no questions asked.
 
got mine today (16GB white)


my silent switch needs some pressure to switch on/off. but 1 finger is enough
my friends one goes very easy.

What about urs...what is normal?
Are there manufactoring differences?
 
Just an update...I called Apple and set up a repair so I'm sending it in tomorrow. Just as I was packaging it up today my brother was wondering why I was sending it in as you couldn't see anything wrong with it by just looking at it, so I showed him how hard it was to switch the silent switch back and forth. Right as I showed him the switch fell off completely...looks like the switch requiring alot of force eventually leads to it coming off completely.
 
Mine is harder then my first gen, but id rather it be little harder...Or should i just goto the apple store incase its broke?
 
From my experience of playing with several phone at an Apple store.
Some are harder to turn than others...
If it has the "click" noise, then it most likely is NOT broken, if it doesn't, then it probably is broken.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.