Then why put them out there? If the expected run time is two hours, then the specifications should list two hours. Two hours is nowhere near eight hours. That's not a minor embellishment if the stated specification is four times larger than the actual runtime.
It's not an embellishment, it's the higher numbers they've gotten that can be considered to not be outliers, when testing them under conditions that they've posted on their website. But none of these numbers are four times higher than the expected run time, unless you're comparing something like wifi browsing with FaceTime on cellular data, but then you're not making a fair comparison.
When I look at runtimes for critical systems, they will list the runtime at load under conditions certain. Sometimes I get more, but I know what the minimum is and how not to overload. It's the same with the portable computers, or laptops. Apple says that the MacBook Pro has a seven-hour battery. No, it doesn't; the specifications have overstated the runtime by approximately four hours. When I look at a critical system, its battery specification lists N hours, and they mean N hours at some specific temperature, pressure, and load that can be defined by the customer.
I've never gotten only three hours out of my early 2011 MBP 13". I've yet, after two years, to use the charger during a work day.
A few weeks ago I was at home sick, using the laptop as my entertainment. I watched a movie, surfed the web and edited some photos. I got more than four hours out of it before I plugged it in, and that was before it had warned me about low battery...
A phone this expensive should not have to lie about its battery runtime specifications. The specifications page for the iPhone says "Video playback: Up to 10 hours." That's not as ambiguous as the Apple laptop specifications. It says that I can do video playback for up to ten hours. If it only lasts one or two hours under this load condition, then saying ten hours would be a lie. So, which is it, and if this specification can't be believed, then how can anyone believe the rest of the specifications as stated?[/QUOTE]
Well, why don't you buy a movie from iTunes store and let it play on repeat, mimicking the settings Apple used, and let us know how long the battery lasted?
http://www.apple.com/iphone/battery.html