RobH said:
I've seen published details that indicated that the contract of at least one major label included the possibility of revisiting pricing.
It tells me that they don't want to admit to lying. Steve Jobs has publicly claimed in the past that everyone gets the same deal.
Kudos to the indies for exposing that lie.
1. Apple would never agree to a better deal with the indies than the major labels.
2. Since they're back to the negotiating table, there must be something to negotiate about.
3. If Apple was offering the same deal to the indies, there wouldn't be anything to negotiate about.
QED.
You seem to be working under flawed assumptions.
First, I don't recall Apple claiming publicly that everyone gets the same deal. I remember that he privately told the American indies that last year. But that was a) private and b) last year.
Second, Apple may now desire to have major parameters fixed but still leave some room for negotiation. This would not contradict any public statements made in regards to European negotiations (because there haven't been any)
Third, item #3 from your list is blatently false because you're ignoring the possibility that the European indies are the ones who are now willing to bend.
If you're going to argue with a law student you're going to have to do better before declaring QED. Nice try, though