You don't say...
----------
It's not an odds game though with a case for some people. Some people buy a case because they want ALL of the phone protected. I am one of those. I simply don't see the point of buying an open bottom case.
My wife was disappointed too... she puts her phone in her purse where it is more prone to getting rubbed by something than anywhere else. Undoubtedly something will find the raw metal at some point in there.
I don't think anyone is buying a case with the thought they are going to drop the phone. But, once again, this goes back to the aspect of full protection. If I am going to buy a case for my phone, I may as well get completely protection. otherwise I am happy just going case free.
If the case works for you, splendid! No reason to attempt to invalidate another person's opinion on why said case doesn't work for them.
Why is my statement "invalidating" but the other person's was not? I was simply replying to a question. In the end, it's a phone. And if you can never see the surface because it's covered in case, then what does it matter if it gets scratched? you're never looking at the surface anyway.
as for the large headphones thing - I'm not so sure "beats by dre" have the same size plug as my $500 Shures but we'll see. I hope so, because I ordered that case.