I'm in the market for a new keyboard for my 2007 Al iMac. My current keyboard is the Al wired apple one that came with the iMac and its great but the comma stopped working and i popped off the key trying to clean it and cant seem to get it back on (and comma still doesnt work). My current keyboard is pretty quiet but still not silent. I have a silent mouse (the clicks make no noise) and was wondering if there is a mac keyboard that was truely silent. searches seem point me to either the apple keyboard or the logitech solar wireless keyboard as being the quietest 'normal' keyboards. I like the layout of the apple wireless keyboard since i never use the number pad. I wish they still made the A1242 but those seem rare and expensive now. anyways, my main question is, are the key noises from the logitech solar the same as the noises from the apple keyboards? is there an option i'm missing? thanks!