MacRumors

macrumors bot
Original poster
Apr 12, 2001
54,147
15,953



Fast Company published a report this week exploring why third-party accessories that make use of Apple's Smart Connector remain few and far between, almost two years after the connector first debuted on the iPad Pro. The magnetic Smart Connector allows the iPad Pro to communicate with and power compatible accessories, like the company's own Smart Keyboard, without the hassle of wires.

The first supporting third-party accessory, Logitech's Create Smart Connector keyboard, launched the same day as the iPad Pro in late 2015, shortly followed by the Logitech charging base, and more recently a Logitech keyboard for the 10.5-inch iPad Pro. However, this close partnership between Apple and Logitech is one of the reasons for the dearth of Smart Connector accessories from competing vendors, according to the report.

smartconnector-800x325.jpg
"With an iPad Pro keyboard on the market already, we are evaluating the market's appetite for another iPad Pro keyboard and identifying if there are any gaps that we can fill," a spokeswoman for Incipio told Fast Company. "So we are developing with having a point of difference in mind rather than developing to be quick to market."
Other issues are said to relate to procuring Smart Connector components, with manufacturers reporting longer lead times compared to other accessories, making them time- and cost-prohibitive. "For a business like us, we've got a very rapid product development cycle," said one vendor source, who asked to remain anonymous. "When you've got a long lead time component that's close to six months, that's just not tenable."

logitechcreateblack-800x444.jpg
Logitech Create Smart Keyboard

Meanwhile, some accessory makers simply preferred Bluetooth as a better fit, especially for iPad keyboards, with more room for maneuver in terms of accessory design. For instance, the Smart Connector only works with keyboards in landscape mode, whereas some users prefer to type in portrait orientation. The issue of Bluetooth battery life has also been minimized, with smaller batteries now lasting for months rather than weeks.

There are only four Smart Connector accessories currently on the market - three offered by Logitech, one by Apple. Fast Company was told by Apple that multiple companies are now developing Smart Connector accessories, but going on this report, iPad Pro owners looking to further exploit the potential of Apple's proprietary connector could be in for some wait yet.

Article Link: Lack of iPad Pro Smart Connector Accessories Blamed on Long Wait Times for Components
 
  • Like
Reactions: AngerDanger

twinlight

macrumors 6502a
Sep 4, 2016
663
495
Can't really imagine any other accessories than charging stand and keyboards. So why would anyone get in when they already are made?
 
Comment

Telos101

macrumors regular
Apr 29, 2016
219
886
Ireland
Can't really imagine any other accessories than charging stand and keyboards. So why would anyone get in when they already are made?

From the linked article:

Looking ahead, though, the real advantage for the Smart Connector isn’t just the hassle-free, powered connection, but the possibilities it could open up for the iPad as a whole. Imagine, for instance, a keyboard that could charge the iPad through a built-in battery, or one with extra storage that integrated with Apple’s new Files app in iOS 11. Perhaps there’s even room for more kinds of input devices, such as a MIDI keyboard dock that didn’t require toting around an extra Lightning cable and stand.

The Smart Connector is still full of potential. Now peripheral makers just have to realize it.
 
Comment

DBZmusicboy01

macrumors 6502a
Sep 30, 2011
969
530
Smart connector is a failure. It’s not even coming to the iPhone 8 so it’s only a iPad Pro feature. But it makes no sense since the lightening port can be used for keyboards and stuff.
 
  • Like
Reactions: c0ppo and Wackery
Comment

ouimetnick

macrumors 68040
Aug 28, 2008
3,306
5,184
Beverly, Massachusetts
Smart connector is a failure. It’s not even coming to the iPhone 8 so it’s only a iPad Pro feature. But it makes no sense since the lightening port can be used for keyboards and stuff.


Similar to Thunderbolt. They hyped it at first and then did nothing to sell people on it. Although I’m pretty sure that was Intel’s fault, Apple could have marketed it more heavily.
 
Comment

Dimka

macrumors member
Jan 23, 2007
48
34
San Francisco
Those are all lame excuses by manufacturers that do not really value good UX and do not want to have any non short turn around products.
Usually in cases like that first party should be more proactive
 
  • Like
Reactions: LiveM
Comment

MH01

Suspended
Feb 11, 2008
12,107
9,298
Huh?

Thunderbolt is absolutely taking off. That it uses the USB C connector makes it even more brilliant.

TB ....going back to TB1 is not taking off. When it comes to the lastest machine , most are just using it with USB-A, the actual TB functionality remains unused.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Appleaker
Comment

bacaramac

macrumors 65816
Dec 29, 2007
1,420
83
Not sure what you people are talking about. Love Smart Connector on 2017 iPad Pro 12.9. I’m using LogiBase and use iPad more as a desktop vs an iPad. It leaves lightning port open for SD card reader. Yes it only charges if, but that’s all I needed from it. Landscape mounted iPad and open lightning port.
 
  • Like
Reactions: macTW and Appleaker
Comment

NinjaHERO

macrumors 6502a
Aug 29, 2008
942
1,139
U S of A
I love my Logitech Keyboard. Makes typing on my Ipad a breeze. But I'm always down for more options. Bring on more keyboards please.
 
Comment

Berti10

macrumors regular
Jan 24, 2012
179
345
Remember, when the iPhone 7+ was said to get this connector? Can imagine, the next iPhone gets a smartbattery that snaps magneticaly to the iPhone and charges the phone. And also being charged by the iPhone when it charges.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JuBe
Comment

szw-mapple fan

macrumors 68020
Jul 28, 2012
2,317
2,347
Smart connector is a failure. It’s not even coming to the iPhone 8 so it’s only a iPad Pro feature. But it makes no sense since the lightening port can be used for keyboards and stuff.

Can you seriously imagine a keyboard with a cable connecting to the lightning connector? That seems like the worst UX design decision ever, especially for a portable device like the iPad.
 
Last edited:
Comment

rizzo41999

macrumors 6502
May 27, 2009
398
1,018
MA
I'd be open to try some of these should they ever be developed. However, I'm hesitant about the Apple keyboard. I'm not too keen on the fact is doesn't provide full protection to the iPad.
 
Comment

simonmet

Cancelled
Sep 9, 2012
2,666
3,659
Sydney
Apple has always done a great job with their port designs. It’s just hard to compete USB and increasingly wireless.

Just because it’s niche doesn’t mean it’s bad. FireWire and then Thunderbolt 1 and 2 both had weak wider appeal but the few times I used it (to transfer files between Macs) it was fantastic and way faster than USB at the time.

I can kind see a market for iPhone cases that utilise the smart connector were it to exist on the iPhone. Take Apple’s own battery cases for example.
 
Comment

farewelwilliams

Suspended
Jun 18, 2014
4,966
18,032
From the linked article:

Looking ahead, though, the real advantage for the Smart Connector isn’t just the hassle-free, powered connection, but the possibilities it could open up for the iPad as a whole. Imagine, for instance, a keyboard that could charge the iPad through a built-in battery, or one with extra storage that integrated with Apple’s new Files app in iOS 11. Perhaps there’s even room for more kinds of input devices, such as a MIDI keyboard dock that didn’t require toting around an extra Lightning cable and stand.

The Smart Connector is still full of potential. Now peripheral makers just have to realize it.
IIRC smart connector has pretty slow data transfer speeds.
 
Comment

alfonsog

macrumors 6502
Jul 17, 2002
408
337
Cape Coral, FL
Well there’s only been 4 devices ever made with smart connector and for a while there was only 1 device which has a sequel now so of course development is slow to start.
 
Comment

ApfelKuchen

macrumors 601
Aug 28, 2012
4,064
2,626
Between the coasts
Smart connector is a failure. It’s not even coming to the iPhone 8 so it’s only a iPad Pro feature. But it makes no sense since the lightening port can be used for keyboards and stuff.

Yeah, when you assume that everything Apple does is a failure.

Smart Connector has advantages over the Lightning port, and Lightning port has advantages over Smart Connector. Lightning is a far more versatile interface, delivering higher data transfer rates, among other things. Smart Connector's advantages are primarily mechanical. Bluetooth also has its advantages and disadvantages. There is still no one-size-fits-all solution for connectivity.

As someone who has a Smart Keyboard, I appreciate the strong, magnetic/mechanical bond between the keyboard and device, and that an accidental separation of the keyboard from the iPad will not put stress on a connector/port. You can essentially rip that keyboard from the iPad with no risk of harm to the iPad and minimal risk to the keyboard/cover.

Sure, that strong, magnetic bond could also be used by a Bluetooth keyboard, but as someone who's been through a variety of accessory keyboards for both iPhone and iPad, Smart Keyboard is by far the easiest to use - no batteries to replace/charge, no pairing. I can keep typing for as long as the iPad has power, and the iPad's Lightning port is free so that I can charge the iPad while I work.

I don't think Apple ever expected to see a large number of Smart Connector-based products. It wasn't created to generate oodles of licensing revenues from the likes of Logitech, or a standard that would be adopted industry-wide. It would be successful so long as Apple could sell a reasonable number of Smart Keyboards, and if the keyboard would be a viable selling point for iPad Pro. Since "physical keyboard" is one of the top requirements for "laptop replacement," a well-executed accessory keyboard was a necessity. I think they did a fine job.
 
Comment
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.