Laptop or netbook?

[calsci]

my friend has a really good question. he wants to buy a notebook/laptop or netbook.

here is what he does on a normal bases.

"well if i were to get a laptop i would use it for: my music, internet, probly reports, maybe some games. and of course i want it as cheap as possible...what would you recommend"

i wasen't sure. as you can see he is tight on cash. any recommendations.

 

[jmann]

Maybe he should get a refurbished white MacBook. They are pretty inexpensive. What is his price range?

 

[mkrishnan]

Besides how much he wants to spend...

- What games would he want to play?
- How important are size, weight, and battery life?
- When does he want to purchase it?

Netbooks will play older games, and there are a couple that have the Ion that may do a little bit better than that, but they're going to be pretty limited in terms of game playing.

If weight, size, and battery life are no concern, and money is a huge priority, that probably points towards a Windows 7 notebook, if he can wait until it comes out, or possibly getting one running Vista now with a free Win7 upgrade.

Otherwise, yeah, the refurb MB 13" plastic / C2D is a pretty good option too.

 

[calsci]

he is not a mac guy (i tried to convert him). and his price range is sub $500.

battery life and performance (translated how "snappy" it feels) is what would be key right now.


ill ask next time i talk to him for some more information.

 

[miles01110]

Have fun typing anything more than a one-line e-mail on a netbook.

 

[rhinosrcool]

Check them out

Have fun typing anything more than a one-line e-mail on a netbook.

Nonsense! Most netbooks, with a 10" screen or larger, have keyboards that are over 90% of a full-sized keyboard. Typing on them is very comfortable.

What your friend needs to do, is go to someplace like BestBuy or Microcenter, where they have display models, and check them out.

 

[J&JPolangin]

I have an Asus 1000H that's ~1.5 yrs old and while its very good at what it does (with 2GB RAM and a 250 HDD), I would recommend getting any netbook with at least the Atom N280 processor/motherboard combo as it is faster than the N270 combo in my "old" unit... the battery life is better, the FSB is faster and the CPU is also faster...

 

[clyde2801]

Your friend should do some research online and go to a best buy to try out the models listed. Some of he later 10" models (like the dell mini 10v or hp mini) do have very usable keyboards; for me, the right shift key and trackpad has been the bane of many of them.

Any atom processor with one gig or more should do basic internet tasks, but seem to choke on streaming live video; they seem to like flash even less than macs do.

No netbook is perfect, and have some limitations due to size and cost. Even the hp mini has a messed up trackpad with mouse buttons on its sides and the dell mini 10v has a half a$$ed apple integrated trackpad and a two hour maximum on its standard configuration 3 cell battery.

If your friend finds a model that he is sure he can live with, he can then look on CL for a slightly used model for a bigger discount. Good luck!

 

[mackhydr4]

my friend has a really good question. he wants to buy a notebook/laptop or netbook.

here is what he does on a normal bases.

"well if i were to get a laptop i would use it for: my music, internet, probly reports, maybe some games. and of course i want it as cheap as possible...what would you recommend"

i wasen't sure. as you can see he is tight on cash. any recommendations.

I think in your friend's case, he should budget for a $350-400 netbook, use it then if he's not happy with it, sell it(or exchange it for a laptop within the return period).

I just picked up a 15.6 compaq laptop for $349 (well, $400 including taxes and before rebate). I will be using it primarily for networking and developing VMware OSes. I know enough about computers to maximize their usefulness and workaround the limitations (I also have a Macbook Air to complement the company gateway laptop).

The key is to actually use the technology, and the work (or play) you will be doing on it should be the deciding factor on what to purchase.

We can debate the merits and disadvantages, but until you actually try something, it is just speculation. People's actual computing differ, and perception of what is acceptable performance also differs.

My point is, what is not good enough for some people, may be a perfect fit for others.

 

[keekl]

Nonsense! Most netbooks, with a 10" screen or larger, have keyboards that are over 90% of a full-sized keyboard. Typing on them is very comfortable.

What your friend needs to do, is go to someplace like BestBuy or Microcenter, where they have display models, and check them out.

I unfortunately have massive hands~regular keyboards are even a tad on the small side for me..but if I had smaller hands I'd snag a netbook.

 

[leighonigar]

I have a netbook, a desktop with a 23" screen and an old iBook g4 12". I never use the netbook. I would advocate getting a full-sized faster, bigger-screened laptop for not much more. The only reason to get a netbook is its small size, if you don't need it to be small then they're not for you.

 

[sishaw]

I unfortunately have massive hands~regular keyboards are even a tad on the small side for me..but if I had smaller hands I'd snag a netbook.

I'm in the same situation. While I much prefer my iBook (I guess roughly equivalent to the base MacBook), my netbook (MSI Wind) is usable, but not really comfortable to type on. I can hook it to my 40" TV with a VGA cable and use a wireless keyboard/mouse with it, which is what I'm doing now. It works reasonably well.

Still, if this were to be my only computer, I would go with a full-size laptop. The main advantage of the netbook is portability, for which you sacrifice power and size.