Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Hard Drive failures

My experience with Leopard:

1. I installed Leopard in my Imac of 18 mths old. A few days later the Imac had totally died.

2. I decided to buy a new Imac (I was thinking of upgrading anyway) and use the hard drive from my old Imac as a backup disk with Time Machine.

3. After a couple of weeks problems started: BU could not be found after reboot, Disk utilities would not find disks...I reinstalled Leopard and the same problems with BU occurred; I also did a clean install. Then the output from the headphone socket failed. I was advised by support to return it to the store for repair. Genius advised that the hard drive and motherboard were defective and gave me a new Imac.

4. The replacement lasted less than two days before strange things started to happen and then eventually I got question marks on boot up. Apple support gave me some tests to perform before the question mark issue and advised that the hard drive was defective. Once again I returned it to the store and the Imac was replaced. This time with Leopard preinstalled.

It may be a coincidence that the two macs had problems while using an external hard drive (from previous Imac in an enclosure) but I have not used it with this Imac.

Incidently on both Imacs, Disk utiility and Tech tool showed not problems with the drives or file structures.

Should I take a chance and reconnect my external drive and use Time machine
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.