Can't decide at all. Had a defender for my 4s but got sick of the bulkiness. I love how slim the life proof is and the fact that it's waterproof is cool, but the main thing that concerns me is the screen not being as touch sensitive as the defender. I also read there might be issues talking through it. I can get a life proof for $55 on amazon, if I do would it be weird to get a white one for my black iPhone? The defender I'm considering is $24, although the price matters I'm more concerned with form and function.