So I am almost 100% sure I got the setting right. Some of my mail is perfect, the response back and forth is just the message and not all that junk below. While other message for whatever reason have the full message below them... It is totally hit or miss. Sometimes it works sometimes its a mess. I am coming from gMail. Is this because these are "old" threads? Will going forward with new threads, from the beginning of it that is, be cleaner since it "Mail" was involved with it all along? Trying to way the pro/cons of this vs. Sparrow... The search is lighting fast and probably better than gMails. It got better integration with other apps too (things).