Looking for silent HDD for Macbook Pro 208 Penryn

[santino80]

Hi,

i'm looking for a really silent HDD for my MB Pro. The HDD in my stock base MB Pro is a FUJITSU MHY2200BH. It makes a permanent "fan-like" background noise. Can someone recommend a silent 200-250GB HDD? (doesn't matter whether 5400rpm or 7200rpm).

 

[bcaslis]

Hi,

i'm looking for a really silent HDD for my MB Pro. The HDD in my stock base MB Pro is a FUJITSU MHY2200BH. It makes a permanent "fan-like" background noise. Can someone recommend a silent 200-250GB HDD? (doesn't matter whether 5400rpm or 7200rpm).

Fujitsu tends to be a quiet drive. I sincerely doubt you will find something much quieter. The Hitachi 7k200 for example is a much louder drive.

 

[chrisbeebops]

The only way you are going to get a silent HDD is to use a solid state drive. Unfortunately, it will cost much more for much less storage.

If you get a lower rpm drive (4200 or 5400rpm), they tend to be quieter than the 7200rpm drives (but slower drive also means lower performance).

 

[AliensAreFuzzy]

Samsung Spinpoint drives are very quiet in my experience.

 

[santino80]

Samsung Spinpoint drives are very quiet in my experience.

what do you think about Samsung SpinPoint P120 250GB - 7200rpm?

http://www.computergiants.com/items/one_item.asp?part=117313

 

[bcaslis]

I've personally never heard a 7200rpm drive that is quieter than a 5400rpm drive. The "spinning fan" noise you dislike on your current drive is almost certain to be louder on a 7200rpm drive.

 

[markrivers]

Hi,

i'm looking for a really silent HDD for my MB Pro. The HDD in my stock base MB Pro is a FUJITSU MHY2200BH. It makes a permanent "fan-like" background noise. Can someone recommend a silent 200-250GB HDD? (doesn't matter whether 5400rpm or 7200rpm).

pardon the ignorance here..
are you working inside a vacuum?

if the current HDD is loud for you.
the only way to go is a solid state drive SDD, just like the one used on the MBA

if it bothers you that much.. i think you really should consider the solid state drive

 

[Watabou]

I have the Hitachi drive 5400 rpm and I only hear it when it is doing some intense work. Most of the time is is completely silent. And even if it does noises, it is silent , not too loud. I'm very happy with this HD.

 

[MarkW19]

Hi,

i'm looking for a really silent HDD for my MB Pro. The HDD in my stock base MB Pro is a FUJITSU MHY2200BH. It makes a permanent "fan-like" background noise. Can someone recommend a silent 200-250GB HDD? (doesn't matter whether 5400rpm or 7200rpm).

The constant "fan-like" noise is probably just that - the fan :s

I have a 2.5 Penryn, with a 7200rpm HD. All I can hear is the FAN constantly making a low noise, at ~2000rpm. I hear the hard drive clicking when reading/writing significant amounts of data, but nothing other than that (and the occasional "click/tick" from the heads parking/moving.

Are you sure it's your HD?

 

[bcaslis]

The constant "fan-like" noise is probably just that - the fan :s

I have a 2.5 Penryn, with a 7200rpm HD. All I can hear is the FAN constantly making a low noise, at ~2000rpm. I hear the hard drive clicking when reading/writing significant amounts of data, but nothing other than that (and the occasional "click/tick" from the heads parking/moving.

Are you sure it's your HD?

Well, it depends on the individual and the environment. At home I can easily hear the 7200rpm drive on my 2.6GHz Penryn. This is separate from the fan noise which I hear also. I respectly disagree with all those who say their drive is silent. It may be relatively silent but it's not silent. Put the MBP next to an MBA with an SSD drive in a quiet house at night and the difference is startling. The difference might not matter to you when you use the MBP (like in an office) but it's not silent.

 

[MarkW19]

Well, it depends on the individual and the environment. At home I can easily hear the 7200rpm drive on my 2.6GHz Penryn. This is separate from the fan noise which I hear also. I respectly disagree with all those who say their drive is silent. It may be relatively silent but it's not silent. Put the MBP next to an MBA with an SSD drive in a quiet house at night and the difference is startling. The difference might not matter to you when you use the MBP (like in an office) but it's not silent.

I agree, it isn't silent.

It's 11:30pm here, and almost fully silent in my house. I can hear a constant fan noise, and of course the read/write clicking from my drive, when required. That's all I can hear though, relating to the drive, not a constant noise, just the clicking, which could be quieter when it happens, I agree.

 

[santino80]

These models are to be considered. http://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/wd-toshiba-join-club,1776-8.html