Oh man sorry this happened to you! My friend recently lost her brand new iphone and forgot to redownload Find My iPhone so it was only tracking her old phone. Just came across this on Buzzfeed i know you're probably upset but this was exactly how my friend felt when she lost her phone- Its called 13 Stages Of Losing Your iPhone, thought it was kind of funny http://www.buzzfeed.com/kmurph125/13-stages-of-losing-your-iphone-if5s