My neighbor was psyched about this premiere because it had the hobbit and some other person from Angel and 24 in it, so she Tivo'ed it and roped me into watching it.
I must say, the pilot didn't give me the slightest interest in seeing the next episode. It's like the network's trying to create a scripted drama out of all the Survivor/Fear Factor-type reality shows. The pacing is contrived and predictable--snippets of emotional, human interaction are alternated back and forth with Oh My God! Another Emergency! complications.
And half of those weren't even believable. The plane's crashed into ruined pieces of tortured metal, and yet one of the engines is still functioning enough to suck one of the Survivors into it? Riiiiight. Man, that's one well-made plane: In Pieces, and Stiiiiill Going!!
Further, the Hollywood "oooh! 'splosions!" rule is heartily in effect, as the unfortunate suckee makes said engine explode furiously. And then the heavy bit of wreckage teetering ever so precariously overhead *just* misses the pregnant woman--of course!--and BOOM! explodes too! even though it only seemed to be the twisted off top of the fuselage and showed no sign of containing any flammable substance whatsoever. And BOOM! this makes the other engine explode too! 'Cause, y'know, mechanical stuff's like, well, explosive. We all know that from countless action flicks with huge pyrotechnic budgets, right?
Don't even get me started on the mysterious beastie. Yes, it rattles and rolls about in the spooky darkness....but evidently this obviously horrifically carnivorous Thingy is still afraid enough of fire and large groups of people not to attack the beach or chew up the bodies in the front chunk of the plane left unattended in the jungle. And, despite its ravenous hunger, it just sorta chews the pilot up a bit, then leaves him mostly whole in a branch. Come on. Any carnivore worth its sharp pointy teeth is going to actually EAT its food. Are we supposed to believe it has merely cached him for later?
But I guess that's why its attack convinces the three of them to leave the only cover between there and the beach to run away from something that's obivously bigger and faster than them, through thick jungle, without weapons! Oooooh! The DRAMA!!!
The writing and character interaction would have to have been a heckuva lot better to make this overwrought manipulation of every dramatic mechanism at all interesting. Even the hints at revelations of the motivations and secrets of the various castaways seems like a hackneyed reassembling of every series that's used the whole "wildly different people forced together in emergency situation!" schtick before. Meh.
/rant
*cough* If you liked the show, I apologize for my tone, but y'know....just being my usual, tactlessly honest and mulishly opinionated self.