Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I don't use Photoshop, but I do encounter dialogs appearing on different monitors at times. It's a constant annoyance in one application in particular, Moneydance Personal Finance. It happens in other applications as well, but sporadically.

I'm going to pay more attention and see if it relates to which monitor is the main monitor.
 
I just read this thread and was interested to see how SM can make a difference to the way I work and so turned on Stage Manager, but I'm struggling to see what's so different other than having an image of your open windows on the left of the screen. Am I missing something?
 
  • Like
Reactions: zevrix
I really wanted to like Stage Manager, but I think decades of Finder experience (and many years of Mission Control) have made it hard for me to adjust. I do love the way Stage Manager cleans up after itself, but I just always find myself fighting to get windows to be where I want them. Maybe if I stuck with it for a couple months I'd get used to it.
 
It's good to hear a word from someone that just likes it. It doesn't suit me on Ventura, but I've found it interesting and kind of cool on the iPad.
The Mac already has some very robust ways to manage workspaces whereas iPadOS has a huge void to be filled in that regard. If I relied on an iPad to get day to day work done I'd definitely prefer Stage Manager over whatever arcane series of swipes the iPad usually requires to get out of one-app-at-a-time mode.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Starfia
The Mac already has some very robust ways to manage workspaces whereas iPadOS has a huge void to be filled in that regard. If I relied on an iPad to get day to day work done I'd definitely prefer Stage Manager over whatever arcane series of swipes the iPad usually requires to get out of one-app-at-a-time mode.
"Arcane swipes" was amusing.

I suppose self-solving element to that conundrum is its conditional nature – since you consider them arcane, you presumably won't prefer an iPad for such work. Perhaps that means you would if swipes were profoundly demoted, but since iPad has unwaveringly been explicitly "touch-first" through all this evolution I imagine you'd always feel a little like you were fighting it on that level.
 
I really like stage manager on macOS, iPadOS though is a whole different story...
This is funny, only because I love it on my iPad with External Monitor. If I am home, this is really the only way I use my iPad. Haha. I don’t use it on the main iPad though. Only with the external display.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Starfia
"Arcane swipes" was amusing.

I suppose self-solving element to that conundrum is its conditional nature – since you consider them arcane, you presumably won't prefer an iPad for such work. Perhaps that means you would if swipes were profoundly demoted, but since iPad has unwaveringly been explicitly "touch-first" through all this evolution I imagine you'd always feel a little like you were fighting it on that level.
Yeah, I'm sure if I used iPadOS I'd get used to it. But I don't think the gestures are very intuitive to begin with. It just seems very easy to have something unexpected happen, and none of it seems particularly discoverable.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Starfia
Tried it many times, on MacOS and iPadOS, hated it every time. Spaces + Mission Control =win on the Mac. On the iPad, Split View works just fine, I never understood the hate for it.

If Apple really wanted to automate window management, they should have brought that to Spaces + Mission Control on the Mac, and brought that same interface to iPadOS.
 
I really can't get on with it. If I just want to use the calculator to add-up some stuff I'm looking at on the web then when I click on Calculator in the dock, the browser disappears.
Just drag and drop calculator from stage manager.
 

Attachments

  • Screenshot 2023-03-04 at 9.27.27 PM.png
    Screenshot 2023-03-04 at 9.27.27 PM.png
    1.1 MB · Views: 94
I really wanted to like Stage Manager, but I think decades of Finder experience (and many years of Mission Control) have made it hard for me to adjust. I do love the way Stage Manager cleans up after itself, but I just always find myself fighting to get windows to be where I want them. Maybe if I stuck with it for a couple months I'd get used to it.
That's me as well. I tried it and thought meh, I went back to mission control. It accomplishes pretty much the same thing for me.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ignatius345
I just read this thread and was interested to see how SM can make a difference to the way I work and so turned on Stage Manager, but I'm struggling to see what's so different other than having an image of your open windows on the left of the screen. Am I missing something?
nothing really just there are apps there on the left instead of the bottom.
I think I turned off stage manager for good.
that feature is just another step in doing a computer task, which we eliminated in 200?
I need to figure out a command on how to go back to an app l
ike mail when we get log in codes, the back to safari, that would be nice!
 
  • Like
Reactions: scouser75
What if Calculator isn't "in" stage manager?
First, you launch Calculator (from the dock or through Spotlight or however you normally launch apps). Then, when you're not using it, it automatically minimizes over to the left side of the screen. If you want to use it again, you click on the minimized app and it comes up. If you want to use it with something that's already in the foreground, you drag it out next to whatever window or app you're actively working on.
 
For me the elephant in the room is the significant amount of space taken up by Stage Manager on the left side. I just have too much need for the whole screen, too often, so as much as I try to be open to change and new things, I can’t enjoy Stage Manager, nor understand its benefits really. I guess everyone’s workflow is different and some people are okay with smaller windows?
 
nothing really just there are apps there on the left instead of the bottom.
I think I turned off stage manager for good.
that feature is just another step in doing a computer task, which we eliminated in 200?
I need to figure out a command on how to go back to an app l
ike mail when we get log in codes, the back to safari, that would be nice!
Yup, mine is off for good too. Far too finicky whilst working with multiple docs and apps.
For me the elephant in the room is the significant amount of space taken up by Stage Manager on the left side. I just have too much need for the whole screen, too often, so as much as I try to be open to change and new things, I can’t enjoy Stage Manager, nor understand its benefits really. I guess everyone’s workflow is different and some people are okay with smaller windows?
Same here. I work from a 16" screen so screen space is much needed.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MBAir2010
Stagemanager has two settings; if you disable one of them, SM will auto-hide and will no longer take space away from windows and desktop.

About the calculator-thing; if you drag another app out from SM, the two apps will appear together as a group in SM. And they can be 'ungrouped' by doing the reverse.
 
Stagemanager has two settings; if you disable one of them, SM will auto-hide and will no longer take space away from windows and desktop.

About the calculator-thing; if you drag another app out from SM, the two apps will appear together as a group in SM. And they can be 'ungrouped' by doing the reverse.

If you disable the "Recent applications" setting, then it no longer takes the space away. Thanks, that's a great tip. If I do that though, I don't see anyway to group applications.
 
If you disable the "Recent applications" setting, then it no longer takes the space away. Thanks, that's a great tip. If I do that though, I don't see anyway to group applications.
Works fine. Drag an app out from the SM to group it with the current app.
 
Works fine. Drag an app out from the SM to group it with the current app.

I disabled "Recent applications", which gives me the full desktop, without the icons on the left. I now want to group another app with my current one. Where do I drag it from?
 
For me the elephant in the room is the significant amount of space taken up by Stage Manager on the left side. I just have too much need for the whole screen, too often, so as much as I try to be open to change and new things, I can’t enjoy Stage Manager, nor understand its benefits really. I guess everyone’s workflow is different and some people are okay with smaller windows?
Since the goal of SM is to automate window management, why didn’t Apple just add this automation to Spaces and Mission Control? Why not re-use Mission Control as the holding area for inactive apps, and turn space into stages?

Apple was trying too hard to re-invent the wheel, when they could have improved on an already great interface.
 
Last edited:
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.