Hey, so I just got my new base MBA. Before this I was using a 2016 MPB. I connect my computer to a monitor in clamshell mode. with my MBP, I used MonitorControl which lets me control my monitors brightness using my external keyboard because my monitor supports DDC. But with the new M1 Mac, it isn't working. The app can't read the monitor. Anyone know how to fix this? or must we just wait for an update?
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Lunar/Monitor Control Brightness not working with M1
- Thread starter person123
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
The developer of MonitorControl is aware of this issue/bug. You can track the status of a possible fix with this issue tracker link:
https://github.com/MonitorControl/MonitorControl/issues/323
https://github.com/MonitorControl/MonitorControl/issues/323
Thanks for the link! I'm having the same issue with my Philips 329P9H and I also can no longer control brightness via Control Center either.
Has Lunar been updated to be compatible with M1 Macs? Was thinking of downloading it to control my Dell U3421WE monitor.
There is a known API Support gap regarding DDC in the M1 GPU framework. Until Apple fixes that we are out of luck.
Lunar developer here.
Lunar 4 has been released with support for M1.
You can read more about it here: https://lunar.fyi/#m1
DDC on M1 is still not possible though.
Lunar can work around that in two ways:
- Simulating a brightness change in software using Gamma Tables (same thing that f.lux does for warmer colours)
- Relaying DDC commands through a Raspberry Pi connected to a separate HDMI port of the monitor
Unfortunately no, audio requires DDC.
Someone made a workaround for that too: https://github.com/briankendall/proxy-audio-device
It works like SoundSource, by creating a virtual audio device in front of the real audio device, and controlling the volume in software.
People are saying that the already compiled binary works through Rosetta, but when they compile it natively for M1 it doesn’t work anymore. So you could try the binary from the releases page.
Someone made a workaround for that too: https://github.com/briankendall/proxy-audio-device
It works like SoundSource, by creating a virtual audio device in front of the real audio device, and controlling the volume in software.
People are saying that the already compiled binary works through Rosetta, but when they compile it natively for M1 it doesn’t work anymore. So you could try the binary from the releases page.
Lunar developer here.
Just chiming in to let you know that Lunar 4.5.1 was just released with full support for DDC on M1 Macs (except for the HDMI port of the Mac Mini, that port has never worked)
@southerndoc that means controlling monitor audio is now possible out of the box with Lunar as long as that monitor is not connected to the HDMI port of a Mac Mini.
Just chiming in to let you know that Lunar 4.5.1 was just released with full support for DDC on M1 Macs (except for the HDMI port of the Mac Mini, that port has never worked)
@southerndoc that means controlling monitor audio is now possible out of the box with Lunar as long as that monitor is not connected to the HDMI port of a Mac Mini.
Hey, just to let you know, MonitorControl now has a version that works with M1:
https://github.com/MonitorControl/MonitorControl/tree/experimental/apple-silicon
https://github.com/MonitorControl/MonitorControl/tree/experimental/apple-silicon
Seems to only work when directly connected but not through my USB-C dock. That's a bummer. The whole point of the dock is to have a single connection when I'm at my desk.
It depends a lot on the dock. Some dock manufacturers don't bother to implement DDC forwarding for the command set that Lunar and MonitorControl are using. An app can't surpass that hardware limitation, but Lunar can work around it using Gamma controls for brightness and contrast only.
Please try Lunar and let us know if it works. If it doesn't, it would be helpful if you could mention which dock model is that so that I can write it in Lunar's FAQ as a non-compliant dock.
It is the Caldigit USB-C SOHO dock. It doesn't seem to work unfortunately. I might look into your Raspberry Pi solution. That is quite clever and I have a RPi kicking around somewhere. The biggest problem is I would have to buy a mini-HDMI to HDMI cable.