Mac Mini + HDTV = Next Desktop?

Discussion in 'Buying Tips and Advice' started by wlfsbrg, Jun 15, 2010.

  1. wlfsbrg macrumors newbie

    Joined:
    Jun 15, 2010
    Location:
    Pacific Northwest
    #1
    Hi all, long time lurker first time poster!

    My wife and I have been waiting patiently for the iMacs to get their upgrades, but this morning's stealth update to the Mac Mini has got us thinking this might be the answer to our desktop needs.

    My question though is this: Can you use the Mac Mini and an HDTV (via HDMI) to do normal computing and the like?

    We'd be buying the wireless keyboard and Magic Mouse and we weren't sure if there was anything different from running the Mac Mini plugged into a standard computer monitor.

    Typical usage would be using Adobe CS5, gaming and watching streaming movies.

    Thanks!
     
  2. Hellhammer Moderator

    Hellhammer

    Staff Member

    Joined:
    Dec 10, 2008
    Location:
    Finland
    #2
    Yes, HDTV is just a normal monitor. The biggest issue you might face is that TVs, especially bigger ones have low ppi so text etc isn't so sharp compared to smaller monitor with about the same res. Of course this depends on your TV and how intensive and accurate your CS5 stuff is
     
  3. BigCatz macrumors member

    Joined:
    Aug 30, 2007
    #3
    I had the same set-up for a year, Mac Mini to 37" 1080p Samsung Tv, via DVI/HDMI connector. Worked great!
     
  4. doktordoris macrumors 6502a

    doktordoris

    Joined:
    Mar 14, 2009
    #4
    There is a potential problem. I suffered from it, I bought a mini-mac and wanted to use it with my HDTV.
    I plugged it in but the mini was set to output a resolution which was too great for my TV to display. The only monitor I had laying around was one which lacked DVI inputs, and the only cable which came with the mini had a DVI connector on the end.

    The solution, for me, was to go to a friendly computer shop with my mini, borrow a monitor for a few minutes then plug the mini into the monitor so I could lower the res setting on the mini.

    Then it worked with my TV.

    So, if you have a TV which has a maximum resolution lower than the mini's initial setting, and you don't have access to a monitor with DVI, or you haven't got a cable which allows you to use a VGA monitor (if you have one) there could be a problem getting started.

    doris

    disregard that I suck , I failed to notice the HDMI reference in OP post.
     
  5. Makosuke macrumors 603

    Joined:
    Aug 15, 2001
    Location:
    The Cool Part of CA, USA
    #5
    I seriously doubt this will be a problem with one of the newer Minis or most HDTVs--the HDMI port should tell the mini what resolutions are supported, and nearly any TV with an HDMI port should do at least 720p, which is plenty for the MacOS.

    That said, while this would work perfectly fine (I've used my home theater mini on a 37" TV as a backup desktop on occasion), if you're doing stuff with CS5, this sounds like a bad idea to me.

    Gaming and movie watching, obviously just fine--they're both the sort of thing for which the bigger the screen, the better (in general), and you don't mind sitting far away from what you're doing.

    However, if you're using CS5, normally you're doing something that requires a reasonable degree of pixel-level precision (and, in most cases, color fidelity as well). Given the incredibly low pixel density of any HDTV (other than unusually small 1080p sets, in the <30" range), if you sit at anywhere near the usual monitor distance you're going to be looking at an immense blurry image, and if you sit even a little too far away, you're going to be squinting at invisible pixels.

    Essentially, at the normal roughly arm's length you sit from a monitor, the pixels of a standard monitor (in the 100-125ppi density range) are visible, but not clearly; lean forward a bit, and you can see them more clearly, for precise work; lean back a ways, and they disappear entirely.

    With a TV--let's say a 40" 1080p display--you're going to have to sit somewhere around 5 feet from it to get pixels in the same visible size range as a monitor, and leaning forward or backward won't really make any difference, since it's proportionally much farther away--you'll have to get up and walk closer to see the pixels, if you need to do something precise in Photoshop or whatever.

    Then there's the fact that most TVs (with a few high-end exceptions) use panels designed for high contrast, deep blacks, rich colors, and motion. Which are crappy, crappy things if you're trying to do color-accurate work in Photoshop or Illustrator, even with calibration.

    There's a reason Apple uses IPS panels in all their displays (other than the laptops)--they cost at least three times as much as a comparable TN panel, and wouldn't look as good displaying a movie or game (slower response time, less contrast), but they're drastically better when it comes to color accuracy.

    Bottom line here, sure, it'll work, and it'll look great playing Portal or watching a movie. But unless you like sitting very far from the screen and don't care much about color or precision in CS5, it's probably a bad idea for graphic-specific computing.
     

Share This Page