Is that Alan Tudyk….
I have never watched Fringe…🤭
No, it isn’t. But I can see how one might think it could be.
Fringe remains one of my favourite sci-fi-adjacent series from this century. It did what
X-Files (post-season 2), could not or would not, and it did so much more.
Particularly from season 2 onward,
Fringe has an ineffable grounding about it which feels both plausible and familiar. It shows messy lives and trauma in non-superficial ways. It doesn’t mock neurodivergence. It isn’t afraid of taunting taboos around psychotropic experimentation. Its careful, but deliberate use of licensed music is impeccable. Principal and supporting characters are quirky, yet complex (for a pre-streaming era), bringing still-infrequent nuance to visual storytelling — the kinds of like often get shelved for most TV and film scripts in lieu of simple archetypes, tropes, and baked-in expectations (best known as a “formula”). It has Easter eggs in every single episode and things to decode (for the armchair cryptographers of the world, of which I am
not).
There are several
zag moments when the viewer expects a
zig. With the final, condensed season, the serial storytelling is incredibly strong and carries the contours of deliberately shaping a fine sculpture. Serial storytelling over monster-of-the-week/anthology storytelling is what I prefer generally. Prior to season 5, there’s a (probably required) delicate balance between these two storytelling styles (as network broadcast series were long compelled to deliver), but it was clear the show-runners had found their serial plot lines and strove to weave them in however they could.
If you or
@TheShortTimer or others in the camp of having not seen it are still on the fence, two other things:
Season 1 is a slog, because they were still trying to find that groove, with hints of it only emerging toward the end of that season — its cliffhanger being
the element to snap that serial storytelling into the sharp focus it needed to move ahead for five seasons.
The other is of Abrams as executive producer:
Fringe may the the only series whose writers, under his watch, kept their focus, stayed on the path, and saw it through to the end in a plausible, cogent way. It’s not the meandering, drunken, head-scratching, “world-building” walk
LOST was, or the plodding, ponderous, increasingly ridiculous train derailment
Person of Interest was (sort of echoing
Alias’s end). [I won’t even get into the rigid woodenness of
Person of Interest’s entire spread of characters.]
It’s also understandable why so many other of his other series were cancelled prematurely (
Revolution, Undercovers, Believe… all on NBC, interestingly). [I won’t even dignify his soap-like dramas like
Roadies.] For those, however, like
Alcatraz and
Almost Human (both Vancouver-filmed and both aired on FOX), the makings of a complex series like
Fringe — as well as good casting — were there, but the network (the same as the one green-lighting
Fringe) balked. (Then again, FOX have long been notorious for prematurely cancelling strong, sci-fi-adjacent shows like
Dark Angel and
Firefly.)
(I imagine there are several multiverses wherein FOX also cancelled
Fringe after one season, but somehow let
Alcatraz or
Almost Human live on to a second season. For all the messed up things about our multiverse, I’m glad we at least got 100 episodes of
Fringe with a magnificent conclusion).
EDIT to add one more thing: Something I enjoy about
Fringe and, as I re-watch it,
Alcatraz, is the careful continuity in casting actors whose characters, if related to another principal character, looks plausibly, even genetically related in superficial features, but especially in one’s eyes and face shape. Or, if it’s a look back to when a main character was much younger, the actor cast as that earlier iteration looks as if they could feasibly be the same person/actor from both age levels.
I don’t think I’ve seen this
consistent emphasis on character-relational continuity in casting anywhere outside of stuff Abrams has overseen. This casting emphasis was evident even way back on
LOST (Danielle and Alex, for example), and even, dare I say, carried over to the casting of Adam Driver as Ben Solo (who bore enough plausible features of a baby born of Harrison Ford’s Han and Carrie Fisher’s Leia).