Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

saladiro

macrumors 6502a
Original poster
May 7, 2007
540
2
New York
Hi, I have a sony hard drive camcorder. (model DCR-SR45) I am importing the videos directly to iMovie. On my sony camcorder, I have it set to the highest quality possible. So when I import it, I can view it in a minimal small screen, lets say a box 4" x 4". the image quality is great.

NOW.....when I try to make it bigger, lets say to fit the whole screen, the resolution is horrible. My expectation was that having the hard drive camcorder at the best possible quality setting, I would have no quality viewing issues at full screen, or almost (in my case, its only crisp in a small box, like i mentioned above.)

I called Sony, and they were not so helpful. they said it could be my video card. I have a Mac book pro i think with a 128mb video card. My mac is not even a year old. I guess I was expecting that I would have a superior picture quality after import.

Could the poor quality be due to the video card? can i change settings in iMovie to import better? are there some 3rd party apps that can help me convert it to a higher quality


I bought it for my first new bow, and although the quality is "ok" I really wanted it to be crisp so when I look at it a few years down the road...

pls advise / help
 
According to the sony site the camera records at 720 x 480, your macbook pro is much greater than this so the movie is being stretched to fill the screen, this results in a slightly blurry picture and is unavoidable with a standard definition camera.

If you want sharp movies on such a high resolution screen you need a 720p or even a 1080p camera, this means the movie is made up of more pixels which ends up in giving a sharper image assuming of course the rest of the camera is up to the job :)


And lastly, as a little demonstration, I've attached a small image, 72x48 pixels, a version stretched 200%, note how the stretched version looks blurry, and a version stored at a higher resolution to begin with.
 

Attachments

  • small.jpg
    small.jpg
    937 bytes · Views: 164
  • stretch.jpg
    stretch.jpg
    1.7 KB · Views: 160
  • big.jpg
    big.jpg
    2 KB · Views: 169
According to the sony site the camera records at 720 x 480, your macbook pro is much greater than this so the movie is being stretched to fill the screen, this results in a slightly blurry picture and is unavoidable with a standard definition camera.

If you want sharp movies on such a high resolution screen you need a 720p or even a 1080p camera, this means the movie is made up of more pixels which ends up in giving a sharper image assuming of course the rest of the camera is up to the job :)


And lastly, as a little demonstration, I've attached a small image, 72x48 pixels, a version stretched 200%, note how the stretched version looks blurry, and a version stored at a higher resolution to begin with.

720 x 480. Interesting. Even at the highest quality? It's a great camcorder, but for $400, you get what u pay for

Tks
 
Don't confuse "highest quality" with resolution. The resolution for any specific camera is usually fixed for SD cameras. The "quality" settings have to do with how much compression is applied to the video.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.