Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Erock86

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Dec 7, 2020
2
0
Hello All, My wife currently has a 2011 macbook air. I am looking to upgrade it but cant decide which one to get her. right now i can get her the Intel Macbook for $799 at BB or the M1 at BB for $999. is there anyone who can give some advice im stuck between price and longevity as idk how long apple would support the Intel.

Thanks
 
Hello All, My wife currently has a 2011 macbook air. I am looking to upgrade it but cant decide which one to get her. right now i can get her the Intel Macbook for $799 at BB or the M1 at BB for $999. is there anyone who can give some advice im stuck between price and longevity as idk how long apple would support the Intel.

Thanks
Even on sale, I'd pass on the Intel Air. the difference in performance, and the fan-free experience, is staggering.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Erock86
Even on sale, I'd pass on the Intel Air. the difference in performance, and the fan-free experience, is staggering.
How much of a difference is it...my wife is a teacher and just uses it for Basic Web, Email and zoom. I guess im just trying to find the huge differences between the 2. i did my research and really leaning towards the ARM Processor but also the $200 savings looks good. and do u think the Intel would last 9 years like her other macbook.
 
Do not buy the Intel MBA, the CPU tends to get hot just watching Netflix and fans come on. The new M1 MBA has no fans and runs rings around the 2020 Intel MBA - its about twice as fast and completely silent, with a battery that lasts 16 hours. I know the Intel is cheaper but the M1 is just in a different class. Apple will release new versions of MacOs for Intel for a while, but you can probably only count on 3-5 years of New Versions of MacOs that will run on Intel.
 
How much of a difference is it...my wife is a teacher and just uses it for Basic Web, Email and zoom. I guess im just trying to find the huge differences between the 2. i did my research and really leaning towards the ARM Processor but also the $200 savings looks good. and do u think the Intel would last 9 years like her other macbook.
It's like double the speed and double the battery life; there are plenty of reviews out there which offer those comparisons. The computer might last 9 years, but due to the transition to the M1 platform, I think we'll see developers start to abandon Intel Macs in fairly short order.
 
100% agree with the comments above. You will find that the new version is far superior and the no fans and huge battery life is well worth every dollar. Sell the 2011 for whatever you can get for it or check to see if you can trade it in. No regrets.
 
The only reason to get an Intel Mac now to run Boot Camp! The M1 Mac Book Air now evens plows through video crunching where it couldn’t before with several days of waiting!
 
I have the early 2020 i3 MBA. It's a great machine, and I rarely hear the fan go on. Certainly, I have never heard it while watching Netflix. The performance of the base Intel MBA would be more than adequate for the OP's requirements.

That said, I would buy the M1 MBA for the battery life alone. It sounds like the OP is planning on keeping this laptop for a long time, perhaps 9 years. $200 over 9 years is $22 per year, less than $2 per month. About the cost of the cheapest smallest cup of coffee that you can buy at Starbucks.
 
If she is using it for videoconferencing with Zoom, the M1 makes a lot more sense based on just that part alone IMO. Zoom tends to be CPU intensive, and the Intel MacBook Airs have both weaker CPUs and very weak cooling capability. They tend to get pretty hot with only moderate workloads, and Zoom can push systems surprisingly hard. It can translate to major fan noise and short battery runtimes, as well as a very toasty lower body.

I usually have skepticism towards first generation devices, but the M1 Macs are using an established chassis and Apple has been working with ARM CPUs for over a decade, so there are established designs within these new devices. Further, the M1 Macs do not generate tons and tons of heat, which has historically been one of the top killer of Apple laptops (and often electronic devices in general). And while no one can predict the longevity of any system, the extremely low amounts of heat are promising signs for longevity. The other promising sign is that the transition itself is moving more smoothly than anyone ever could have imagined...Apple has been preparing for this for a very long time, and they have clearly spent tremendous effort on preparing for this moment.

That's not to say the Intel MBA is bad. My brother has one of the most recent i5 MBAs and likes it a lot. However, the M1 improves upon its greatest weakness, and using Zoom a lot really exposes that weakness. As he is using Zoom a ton, he's considering getting rid of his and replacing it with a M1 MBA.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.