Everybody seems to be chiming in on the MacBook Air, so I might as well too.
To me (opinion here), the MacBook Air misses the mark in many ways, but at the same time, I believe it is a computer that needed to happen (I'll explain this later)
Here are some issues, pro's and cons style compared to the MacBook:
Pros:
- Thinner
- Lighter
- Nice looking (subjective)
- Slightly longer battery life?
- MultiTouch Trackpad
Cons:
- Slower Processor
- Less hard drive capacity
- Slower hard drive
- Less connectivity (Optical, firewire, etc)
- Higher price (+$700)
The thinner & lighter thing is cool, but it's no more portable than any other MacBook. The footprint is the same, and the bag you carry it in isn't much different if at all than what you would carry any MacBook in. Also, the trackpad feature will undoubtedly be available on the MB and MBP on their next respective revisions.
So let's sum it up; you get a computer that is not really any more portable, has less connectivity, is slower, has less space, etc, etc, and you pay $700 more for this. Doesn't add up for me. As someone else mentioned, this is more of a second computer, but it is priced at a pro level, and clearly not a pro machine.
However, I said this computer needed to happen...here is what I mean. As impractical as this computer is (based on it's price), this is a great looking and well functioning machine for the right person, which is the consumer level user. I think a realistic expectation is to see this design become the MacBook design, a thin lightweight computer for the consumer, and at the current MacBook pricepoint, people would be all about that. And then, the pro user would have the MacBook Pro, a portable with all of the connectivity and speed that pro users need. I hope that made sense. Again, I think the design and the idea is great, but it's position in the product line makes no sense to me. Unless you are impractical and want to pay a premium for the über-trendy, then it makes complete sense.
I hope they eventually split the line to the MacBook Air design, and a Pro design...I think that would make sense for everyone. My opinion.
Steve