Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

JSMencer

macrumors regular
Original poster
Oct 30, 2007
150
0
What temperature is good for your macbook to run at. I'm usually always around 135-145 degrees. I have smc fan control, and i am running my fan at 3600rpm's please let me know what you think about the subject.
 
do you think it could be cause of a 7500rpm drive that my laptop feels real hot
 
What temperature is good for your macbook to run at. I'm usually always around 135-145 degrees. I have smc fan control, and i am running my fan at 3600rpm's please let me know what you think about the subject.

135-145 Fahrenheit right?
 
I've set my RPM and kept the temperatures to around 102 F or so as long as im not running my VM.

smcFanControl is great. you can also set profiles to different speeds by just one click. (or two maybe, lol)
 
I modded mine a lot but my 2.4GHz is running...

~40C/104F or below on idle or really basic stuff
~Low 60s (C)/140s (F) on a very, very heavy load
 
Ouch HOT!

My MB Alu 2.4 stock is running on average 75C. I looked in istat and the only thing running was iphoto, and that was running only at 1.9%. I brought it up to the apple store hoping to get a replacement or at least figure out what was going on. He said oh ummmm, I don't know what it should be running at. I don't pay attention to the numbers. It is normal for them to run a little warm. My first. MB ran around 45c on average. Too bad that one had 7 bad pixels. What should I do? It has got up to 80C in VMware. Most of the time the fan doesn't come on until 75C. Should I call applecare?
 

Attachments

  • Picture 6.png
    Picture 6.png
    964 KB · Views: 146
  • Picture 7.png
    Picture 7.png
    971.1 KB · Views: 102
My MB Alu 2.4 stock is running on average 75C. I looked in istat and the only thing running was iphoto, and that was running only at 1.9%. I brought it up to the apple store hoping to get a replacement or at least figure out what was going on. He said oh ummmm, I don't know what it should be running at. I don't pay attention to the numbers. It is normal for them to run a little warm. My first. MB ran around 45c on average. Too bad that one had 7 bad pixels. What should I do? It has got up to 80C in VMware. Most of the time the fan doesn't come on until 75C. Should I call applecare?

The temperature that SpeedFan gives isn't that accurate. It's actually really high for some reason. Not sure why. You're probably closer to somewhere around 70c on load.

If the guy said he didn't know what the temperatures at that it should be running at, he's lying to you or he's a really bad employee. I don't know if they'll do much for you though unless your MacBook does something physically/visibly wrong. Go there and complain that your old one was substantially cooler, I guess.
 
85c

The temps I posted were from Istat. I have tried both programs and they both say right now I'm at 85C. Not good. I am worried about the long term effects. What do you think?
 
Go back and this time ask to speak to somebody that won't just give you a BRUSH-OFF answer. The guy's an idiot... he doesn't pay attention what temps they run at?!?! Then why the heck does he work in a computer store?! Ask to speak to the manger if they won't at least LOOK at it..
Idle temps should not be more than 50C, unless you're just blocking the air vents in the back (like keep it on your bed all the time where air can't circulate well).
Go back to the store ASAP and get it looked at.
 
The temps I posted were from Istat. I have tried both programs and they both say right now I'm at 85C. Not good. I am worried about the long term effects. What do you think?

Like I said, iStat/smcFanControl/whatever is not very accurate. You're not running as hot as 85c, but if you're running anywhere near that point there's no doubt that electromigration is occurring. If you keep letting that happen, your CPU is going to have an early death... maybe a couple years. My guess is that if you run it that hot, it won't make a difference because you'll probably end up getting a new laptop before the CPU dies, but I'd still get something done about it.

Edit: I've measured with tools, and via CoreTemp in Windows. CoolBook's temperature is accurate. It's also intuitively obvious that iStat's temperature is off because the CPU is only 1c hotter than the sides of the heatsink. That can't be right.
CoolBook: 42c
iStat Nano: 54c
 
Idle temps should not be more than 50C, unless you're just blocking the air vents in the back (like keep it on your bed all the time where air can't circulate well).

I have it on my bed right now and my temp is 45* C. It's been running after waking from sleep for about half an hour now with firefox running and adium. Not too bad at all.
 
My MB Alu 2.4 stock is running on average 75C. I looked in istat and the only thing running was iphoto, and that was running only at 1.9%. I brought it up to the apple store hoping to get a replacement or at least figure out what was going on. He said oh ummmm, I don't know what it should be running at. I don't pay attention to the numbers. It is normal for them to run a little warm. My first. MB ran around 45c on average. Too bad that one had 7 bad pixels. What should I do? It has got up to 80C in VMware. Most of the time the fan doesn't come on until 75C. Should I call applecare?

Select Show "All Processes" instead of "My Processes" and see if some nasty print job or other background process is taking a lot of CPU %.
 
I've been using SMCfanControl for quite some time. Under heavy load my temps spike up to 90C. Under normal conditions it averages from 60-65. Is this normal?
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.