My wife has a macbook from her freshman year in college that is now 6 years old. I was looking to get her the new pro or air. What do you guys think would be the best option?
Does she complain about the performance, the weight, the display or all of the above?
That should give you an idea about which features are the most important.
The MBA should outperform an older MBP and of course it's the lightest option.
The display of the MBA looks a bit washed out compared to my cMBP even if the 13" MBA does have a few more pixels and obviously the rMBP display is better again.