Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Status
The first post of this thread is a WikiPost and can be edited by anyone with the appropiate permissions. Your edits will be public.
I finally got around to installing the Tahoe beta on my MB Pro 16" M4Max. Runs smooth as silk for me.

While I don't particularly like the GUI, I now think that some of the commentary about Tahoe's readability is overblown. Many of the screenshots people have shared regarding readability issues appear to be specifically set up in a way as to prove a point, and not based on "normal use" by a "normal consumer." For example, I keep seeing people posting screenshots of Music with the name of the song and other text almost completely lost against a background of the album art and/or desktop, etc. My personal reality is that I haven't come across that issue at all.

I could do without all the giant glass bubbles for buttons, etc. But again, for me, I only really notice them if I'm in the Finder – which I very rarely am. I work in apps (including a Finder replacement app called Forklift) many of which use their own GUI (Adobe, Microsoft, etc.) or Apple apps that have a very simple interface where the "problem" doesn't really show itself much anyway.

My personal belief is that, like every other OS design change since Mac OSX was released, people here will complain about the "new" OS and wish Apple would stick with the "old" OS that they spent the previous 18 months complaining about. It's a silly and predictable cycle that apparently will never end, and that simply illustrates that people don't generally like change of any kind. I personally love change, but that's just me.
 
I finally got around to installing the Tahoe beta on my MB Pro 16" M4Max. Runs smooth as silk for me.

While I don't particularly like the GUI, I now think that some of the commentary about Tahoe's readability is overblown. Many of the screenshots people have shared regarding readability issues appear to be specifically set up in a way as to prove a point, and not based on "normal use" by a "normal consumer." For example, I keep seeing people posting screenshots of Music with the name of the song and other text almost completely lost against a background of the album art and/or desktop, etc. My personal reality is that I haven't come across that issue at all.

I could do without all the giant glass bubbles for buttons, etc. But again, for me, I only really notice them if I'm in the Finder – which I very rarely am. I work in apps (including a Finder replacement app called Forklift) many of which use their own GUI (Adobe, Microsoft, etc.) or Apple apps that have a very simple interface where the "problem" doesn't really show itself much anyway.

My personal belief is that, like every other OS design change since Mac OSX was released, people here will complain about the "new" OS and wish Apple would stick with the "old" OS that they spent the previous 18 months complaining about. It's a silly and predictable cycle that apparently will never end, and that simply illustrates that people don't generally like change of any kind. I personally love change, but that's just me.
well said 👍
 
The issue could be that the first betas of both iOS and MacOS 26 were a usability and readability disaster.

Over the following betas, this got pretty much fixed, but the echo chamber of complaints remained.

I waited until the third or forth dev beta (I forget which!) so missed all the excitement, and have liked 26/Tahoe since the start.
 
The issue could be that the first betas of both iOS and MacOS 26 were a usability and readability disaster.

Over the following betas, this got pretty much fixed, but the echo chamber of complaints remained.

I waited until the third or forth dev beta (I forget which!) so missed all the excitement, and have liked 26/Tahoe since the start.
i had no problem with the first betas of either OS, knowing full well that they were, in fact, first betas. i know running betas has consequences; it's what we sign up for if we want to dive in early.
 
I find all the control button in Safari, Mail, and others are too close to the top edge of their windows; there's almost no margin to "grab" a window to move it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: judgeFire
I find all the control button in Safari, Mail, and others are too close to the top edge of their windows; there's almost no margin to "grab" a window to move it.
Getting rid of the dedicated title bar at the top of windows was a big misstep in terms of usability; creating user frustration is not a great design outcome.

I use BetterSnapTool to let me grab a window from anywhere by holding down a modifier key (fn for me), so don't need to hunt for those mythical draggable window top pixels ever again.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.