Agreed, I've been on the mac platform since the MAC SE days and I've never had one single malware issue.Why use an Antivirus on OS X? That's like buying a lamp for a perfectly naturally well lit room.
Why use an Antivirus on OS X? That's like buying a lamp for a perfectly naturally well lit room. In my entire 3 years of having a Mac now, I have had a total of 0 of these OS X trojans.
The built in security system in Snow Leopard detects them anyway. Not to mention you need to actually install them (including entering your admin password) to get them.
A/V software is pretty pointless on OS X.
Actually, it's more like installing a specialized lock that only keeps out burglars from Mars. First, there ARE no Martian burglars roaming around that have ever burglarized anyone. Second, even if there were, how do you know what they look like or how to keep them out? That's how useful antivirus apps are for keeping a Mac safe.Why use an Antivirus on OS X? That's like buying a lamp for a perfectly naturally well lit room.
Actually, it's more like installing a specialized lock that only keeps out burglars from Mars. First, there ARE no Martian burglars roaming around that have ever burglarized anyone. Second, even if there were, how do you know what they look like or how to keep them out? That's how useful antivirus apps are for keeping a Mac safe.![]()
I did read it. I suggest you read the link that simsaladimbamba posted in the 2nd post in this thread. As stated there, any Windows user not running their own antivirus is at a much greater risk of infection from sources other than a Mac user sending a file. The only way a Mac user can get an infected file is to first receive it from a Windows user. It's like saying I'll drive on the access road to keep from running over someone walking around on the freeway. They've got much bigger worries than me. The common sense approach is for every Windows user to run their own antivirus software, so they're protected from threats, regardless of the source.I'd suggest reading my post further up.
I did read it. I suggest you read the link that simsaladimbamba posted in the 2nd post in this thread. As stated there, any Windows user not running their own antivirus is at a much greater risk of infection from sources other than a Mac user sending a file. The only way a Mac user can get an infected file is to first receive it from a Windows user. It's like saying I'll drive on the access road to keep from running over someone walking around on the freeway. They've got much bigger worries than me. The common sense approach is for every Windows user to run their own antivirus software, so they're protected from threats, regardless of the source.
Except it uses system resources and benefits no one but any Windows user who's not prudent enough to run their own AV. If someone wants to do it, that's fine. I prefer not to add to my Mac's workload, simply for the benefit of someone who doesn't care enough to protect their own computer.I get that. But at the same time, running an Antivirus software on your mac shouldn't be such a big deal. So long as the user understands why they should be running it anyway.
You're absolutely right. Of course, there wouldn't be so many threads on this if people took the time to read some of the existing ones before starting new ones.This topic gets bludgeoned every week here on MR
The arguments never change and you could go to any of several dozen threads and read the same thing ad infinitum
Except it uses system resources and benefits no one but any Windows user who's not prudent enough to run their own AV. If someone wants to do it, that's fine. I prefer not to add to my Mac's workload, simply for the benefit of someone who doesn't care enough to protect their own computer.
You're not doing them a favor by shielding them from malware from your Mac, but leaving them exposed to millions of other sources. If you really want to help, get them to install AV on their own system.
Macs cannot run Windows programs or malware, so how do you suppose your Mac could infect a PC unless you deliberately put a a virus exe onto a memory stick and executed it on a PC.Sometimes it's just easier to have an antivirus program running. Again, it isn't helping my Mac, but it is helping me in the long run with my Windows machines. Or in an office setting it's helping the other Windows users...
Macs cannot run Windows programs or malware, so how do you suppose your Mac could infect a PC unless you deliberately put a a virus exe onto a memory stick and executed it on a PC.
It doesn't help anything in the long run and it is simply impossible for OS X to spread a PC virus.
In which the PC antivirus will hopefully find and eliminate the threat. Having the antivirus on your Mac is just a waste of RAM.Whilst these exploits will do nothing on the Mac, simply forwarding this documents to PCs via email can be enough to infect those PCs.
In which the PC antivirus will hopefully find and eliminate the threat. Having the antivirus on your Mac is just a waste of RAM.
Sure -- but that doesn't change the fact that it's possible for a non-AV-running Mac user to infect a PC.
For example, if your business is Mac-based and you forward on a document containing a virus to a client, you're not going to look very good. Even if their AV software removes the threat, it won't instil confidence in you if you're seen to be spreading viruses.
Or perhaps you'd originally written your CV in a Word document on a PC but have been updating it on your Mac. You'd probably want to give that file a quick scan before sending it as part of your job application - just in case it's picked something up whilst being open on a PC.
It's horses-for-courses at the end of the day. I wouldn't run AV on a Mac unless I had a specific need to do so (such as that explained above).